Introduction

Islam is the religion Allah sends prophets with and accepts worship from His servants according to its teachings. The Prophet ﷺ explained every details of the religion in both theory and practice for smooth practice and onward transmission to the coming generations. Imam Abu Dawud reports from Abu Huraira in the Book of Malahim that the Prophet ﷺ says:

(إن هللا عز وجل يبعث لهذه اْلمة على رأس كل ِ مِئة سنةٍ من يُجَد ِدُ لها دينَها)

“Allah will send to this nation at the beginning of every hundred years someone who will renew its religion for it”164 Since our Prophet is the seal of Prophethood, there is no prophet after him. The passage of time and centuries have effect on the weakening the sharia’ah and the religion. For this, scholars from time to time come to reform the religion, reestablish its foundations and repel innovations and weakness from it. This prophesy was fulfilled because; there exist throughout history scholars who come periodically to revive the religion and reform the Ummah. Northern Nigeria was blessed with many Muslim scholars and reformers whose impact reached places far outside the borders of the region. The region had great scholars in the Kamem Borno and Sokoto Caliphate and the Ummah is still benefitting from their intellectual legacies. One of the contemporary scholars of the region who understands the root of the problem facing the region is Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gummi. The problems identified by the Sheikh were ignorance, corruption in religious practices and moral decadence among other spiritual problems. The Sheikh observes that, there is also the effect of the destructive consequences of British colonialism which has gone unnoticed to the generality of people. He observed that, most people are often concentrated on the material exploitation and totally disregard the mental enslavement that followed. It poisoned the mind and thinking of many even among the educated. That is why; whenever there is a problem, they fixed to horizon beyond the borders of their values looking for solutions and even working to achieve approval from those colonial masters who set standards that conflict their needs and values. This according to the Sheikh, this is more than material theft. He added that people will be only successful when their belief, values and need form the basis for their life efforts165. The Sheikh educates, enlightens and made ijtihad to provide practical solution to many issues peculiar to Muslims of the region. The heterogeneous nature of the region made it to be in constant demand of verdicts on emerging issues and the application of some religious injunctions in a Muslim minority area or majority area with non-Muslim minority concerns. The peculiar nature of the issues doubles the need for Ijtihad by native scholars. The Sheikh has revolutionized ijtihad in the region to Sharia’h compliant, maqasid based, people, society and the time considerate for practical and realistic verdicts. This is a model that further demonstrates how the region developed its academic and juristic capacity solving domestic fatwa demands of the region in a practical and realistic manner; as a product of verdicts emanating from scholars who lived in the area and had practical experience of the matter. His ijtihad are numerous due to Sheikh’s being a scholar, jurist, judge and a public figure. The main aim of this paper is to acknowledge the efforts of Muslim Scholars in the region in providing solutions to local emerging issues through Ijtihad and show the importance of relying on indigenous scholars to provide verdicts that are sharia’h compliant in deciding the legal

164 Abu Dawud, Suleiman bn Ash’ath, Sunan Abi Dawud, Shu’aib Arna’ut, ed, Dar Risalah Alamiyyah, 1st edition, 1430, vol. 6, p. 349, Haditih 4291. 165 Gummi, A.M. and Tsiga I.A, Where I Stand, Ibadan, 1994, p. 28 position of emerging issues. The paper also highlights the contributions of the Sheikh to contemporary Islamic thought and reform in Nigeria. The paper uses Shaykh Gummi’ as a case study and focuses on his book “Where I Stand” for in-depth analysis. The work despite being an autobiography, it has account of instances where he highlighted some of his Ijtihad by himself. Content analysis is used to examine the work, identify the instances of Ijtihad and critically analyze them. Other secondary sources on the life and contributions of the Sheikh were used together with classical Islamic works in Hadith and jurisprudence ware also consulted. Conceptual Framework Ijtihad is from the root juhd and jahd166 meaning ability and difficulty respectively167. Ibn Athir said both were used in the linguistic sense in both the Qur’an and Hadith168. Example of where the Qur’an used juhd is the saying of Allah: ( ۡوَٱلَّذِينَ الَ يَجِدُونَ إِالَّ جُهۡدَهُم) “and such who could not find to give charity except what is available to them” Taubah 79. The term here means ability and in the Hadith, the Prophet ﷺ says on one of the best sadaqah: ( ِ الْمُقِل ُجُهْد) “effort of one with little”169. Additionally, an example of where the Qur’an used jahd is the saying of Allah: ( َوَأَقۡسَمُواْ بِٱَّللَِّ جَهۡد أَيۡمََٰنِهِم) “and they swear by Allah their strongest oaths…” Qur’an 6:109 and in the Hadith, the Prophet used to seek refuge from the hardship of affliction: ( كان رسول هللا صلى هللا عليه وسلم يتعوذ من جهد البالء)170 meaning difficulty. Therefore, ijtihad linguistically means exerting effort and using all means to achieve something that could not be easily achieved without efforts171. It is the act of exerting effort and exhausting ability in doing things and it is only used for herculean tasks172 to express reaching the peak of searching. It also means exerting effort in search for a thing173, determining an emerging issue from Qur’an and Hadith through qiyas

Technically ijtihad is the serious effort of the scholar trying hard in searching for knowledge about ruling of Shari’ah the farthest he can go174. It signifies exertion of one’s full strength and capacity to reason deeply on difficult matters, especially in legal issues not explicitly detailed in the Qur’an or Sunnah. It is the emptying of a jurist all his efforts to reach to a ruling to the best of his knowledge175. From the above, we may operationally put ijtihad as the rigorous, independent reasoning and deep mental exertion by a qualified Muslim Jurist to deduce a ruling for new or complex legal issues not explicitly covered by the Qur’an, Sunnah or Ijma’. It is the process of exhausting one’s intellectual capacity, applying interpretative principle using analogy

166 Ibn Manzur, Muhammad bn Mukrim, Lisanul Arab, Dar Sadir, Beirut, 2nd edition, 1414, vol. 3, p. 133 167 Ibn Athir, Mubarak bn Muhammad, al-Nihayah fi Gharib al-Hadith wal-Athar, Tahir Ahmad, ed, Maktabah Ilmiyyah, Beirut, 1399, vol. 1, p. 320 168 Ibn Athir, Mubarak bn Muhammad, al-Nihayah fi Gharib al-Hadith wal-Athar, vol. 1, p. 320 169 Abu Dawud, Suleiman bn Ash’ath, Sunan Abi Dawud, vol. 3, p. 107, Hadith 1677 170Bukhari, Muhammad bn Isma’il, Sahih Bukhari, edited by Mustapha Diban, Dar Ibn Kathir, Damascus, 1443, vol. 5, p. 2336, Hadith 5987.

171 Ibrahim, Muahammad Yusri, Fiqh Nawazil lil Aqalliyat al-Muslimah, Dar al-Yusi, Cairo, 1st edition, 1434, vol. 1, p. 310 172 Ghazali, Muhammad bn Muhammad, al-Mustasfa, Muhammad Abus Salam , ed, Dar Kutub Ilmiyyah, Beirut, 1st edition, 1993, p 173 Ibn Athir, Mubarak bn Muhammad, al-Nihayah fi Gharib al-Hadith wal-Athar, p. 319 174 Ghazali, Muhammad bn Muhammad, al-Mustasfa, p. 342 175 Ibrahim, Mustapha, et al, Mu’jam al-Wasit, Mu’jam Lughah al-Arabiyyah, Cairo, 2nd edition, 1392, v. 1 p. 142 to arrive at a reasoned legal judgment to put Sharia’h relevant to all time. If the mujtahid has all the means and got it right has two rewards and if not one reward176.

Review of Literature

Huzaifa Aliyu Jangebe has a paper titled Islamic Reform in Nigeria: The Contribution of Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi. The paper discussed Islamic reform movement in Nigeria and picked Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi as a model who stood firm to salvage the society from further religious decline during his time due to what he believed that, the cause for the Muslims` decline was their departure from practicing the pristine Islam as laid down in the Qur`an and the authentic Sunnah. In his quest for a solution, Sheikh Gumi articulated a reformative drive. In politics, he was the first reformist to advocate uprightness in the government policies and he was very active in the issue of the political unity of the Muslims in the region. Besides this statement, Sheikh Gumi voiced on the eve of the presidential election of 1983, portrayed the importance of elections in the Muslims society of Nigeria177.

Mujaddadin Zamani Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gummi Rayuwarsa da Zamaninsa by Zakari Muhammad is another work that described sheikh as a reformer of Islam in Nigeria. The work used a unique way of relying on the reports given by people on the sheikh as a reformer. He gave a brief biography of the sheikh, accounts from his school mates, former Nigerian leaders, Muslim Scholars, political leaders, his supporters, students and family. He relied on testimonies of these people to justify Sheikh as a reformer. As a journalist, the author has access to many Nigerian leaders who lived with the Sheikh and reached out to most of them at different time and places and their responses remained of portraying him as an honest erudite scholar who struggled in reforming the society in almost all aspect of Islam.

Ibrahim, Muhammad Mansur has a work on the life and works of the sheikh, Ash-Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gummi: Hayatuhu, Mawaqifahu wa Ara’ahu. The work gave a general biography of the personality. His methodology of da’awa, his call to seeking for knowledge and used good methods in reaching out to people, called for using dalil, established organizations and revive Hadith studies. He fought innovation revive aqidah and preach against some aspects of tasawwuf he considers not in conformity with Islam. He analyze some of his fatwas showing where he agrees with the people and area where he took position contrary to the general perception.

Musa Lawal Funtuwa has compiled some of the answers giving by Sheikh during his teaching sessions and other different occasions under the title Fatawar Abubakar Mahmud Gummi in two volumes. The work contains 720 fatwas given by the Sheikh on different issues. The answers were divided into two sections, the Ibadat and Mu’amalat sections and topics like tauhid, purification, prayer, fasting, zakat and hajj were discussed. Others include transactions, hadud,

176Juwaini, Abdul Malik bn Abdullahi, Waraqat , Abdul Latif Muahmmad, ed, np, 1431, p. 31 177 Jangebe, Huzaifa Aliyu, Islamic Reform in Nigeria: The Contribution of Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi, International Journal of Humanities and Social Science, Vol. 5, No. 9, 2015, p. 177 foods and drinks, education, marriage and divorce. And in the second volume, another section was added where it treated general issues such as history, politics and leadership, and Sufism.

The literature reviewed focus on the personality of the Sheikh, his education and public services, his reform movement and advocating uprightness in government policies and political unity of the Muslims in the region. The works also showed him as a Mufti in the region who provided answers to the spiritual needs of the people trough teaching and fatwa. His methodology of da’awa, establishing religious organizations and revive Hadith studies. This paper will critically analyze some of his ijtihad focusing on some of them he mentioned in his autobiography.

Life, works and legacies of Shaykh Abubakr Mahmud Gummi

Biography: Abubakar Mahmud Gumi was born and raised in a family of Islamic scholarship. His father Malam Mahmud hailed from Shagari. He travelled wide in search for Islamic knowledge where he visited centres like Katsina, Kano and Borno, Dutse and later returned home and settle in places like Gwandu, Jega before finally settling at Gummi. He continued teaching and later served as a judge and died in 1936178. Sheikh Abubakar was born on 7th November, 1924179 and was brought up under his parent`s care, and his father was his first teacher who taught him many books and prepared him for advanced studies. His legal studies in Kano trained him in intellectual discourse and listening to critics and opposing views keeping his mood under control. He started holding religious position right from middle school and this prepared him for future leadership roles. He died on 11th September, 1992180.

Education

Islamic education: The late Sheikh Gumi began his Islamic education under the tutelage of his father. He also studied under one of his father’s senior students Malam Musa. He studied privately under many scholars, either at their homes or wherever he met any of those scholars at Dogon Daji and Sokoto when he went for his elementary and middle schools. When he is leaving for further studies in Kano, one of his teachers, Mallam Junaidu introduced him to a renowned scholar Mallam Kabara to continue teaching him there and he also had other teachers there in Kano like Malam Rabi’u, Malam Aminu Wali, Malm Yakub Zakariya and Malam Siddiq Zaria among others. He also learned from some of the foreign scholars who work at his school in Kano. Formal education: He attended Dogon Daji elementary school and Central Elementary School Sokoto (1933-1936) for his elementary education where he was promoted rapidly to the next class almost on term basis instead of end of session due to his extraordinary performance, Sokoto Middle School (1936- 1942), Sokoto Khadi School in 1942 for a year remedial program before proceeding to Kano law School (1943-1946), School for Arabic Studies in Kano 1950-1952 and the Bakht al-Rida Institute of Education 1953-1955181.

178 Funtuwa, Musa Lawal, Fatawar Abubakar Mahmud Gumi, Hudahuda, Zaria, p. 2 179 Gummi, A.M. and Tsiga I.A, Where I Stand, p.5 180 Funtuwa, Musa Lawal, Fatawar Abubakar Mahmud Gumi, Hudahuda, Zaria, p. 5 181 Jangebe, Huzaifa Aliyu, Islamic Reform in Nigeria: The Contribution of Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi, p. 177

Civil service: He started his career in the public sector with an automatic appointment after graduating from Sokoto Middle School, posted to the office of the Chief Alkali in Sokoto as a scribe to the office of the then chief judge, Sokoto province. After finishing law school 1947- 1948, he was a teacher at Kano law school 1948-49, teacher at Maru 1949, taught in Kano while studying at SAS, continue teaching after returning from Sudan in 1956, first Nigerian Pilgrims Officer in Jeddah 1957, Deputy Grand Khadi 1960 and after two years he was promoted to Grand Khadi, 1962 -1975 making him the first Nigerian to hold that position, member of the management team of King Faisal Bank, founded in 1976. He served as Amirul hajj from 1976-78, adviser to Sir Ahmadu Bello Sardauna and former Head of State, Late Murtala Muhammad, World Muslim League and Islamic Development Bank. He also served as a member of the supreme council of several universities, such as the Islamic University of Madinah, Saudi Arabia, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria and the University of Ibadan, Nigeria. He also headed National Teachers Institute between79-92, and was conferred with prestigious national honor of CFR 1964 and King Faisal award in 87.

Literary Works: Sheikh Gummi is a prolific writer and his works are ambidextrous in the sense that he writes in both Arabic and English, a part from the local Ajami of both the Arabic and Hausa. His literary works cut across the major disciplines in Islamic studies. In the area of Tafsir, he has the Rad al-Azhan ila Maani al-Qur`an and Tarjamar Ma`anonin al-Kur`ani Maigirma. In theology, he wrote Al-Aqidah al-Sahiha bi Muwafaqat al-Shariah, Hal al-Niza` fi Mas´alat Nuzul Isa alaih al-Salat wa al-Salam, Musulunchi da Abinda ke Rushe Shi and Kitab Maratib al-Islam. In Hadith he wrote Tarjamar Littafin al-Arbain al-Nawawiyyah. In ibadat he has Zad al-Haj, Kitab Manasik alhaj wa al-Umra and on Sokoto Caliphate Literature, he translated some to Hausa language like Tarjamar Kitab Nur al-Bab, Tarjamar littafin Hidayat al-Tullab fi Aham Masail al-Din. Moreover, besides these publications, Sheikh Gumi left several unprinted manuscripts182.

Legacies

Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gummi has left several living legacies. He revive the spirit of religiosity among the Northern elite who mostly had western orientation before his da’awah activities. These elite developed spirit of Islam and assisted greatly in propagating Islam at various levels and capacities. The Sheikh taught many students in almost all the places he lived before finally settling in Kaduna, where the impact of his activities was felt more and partly due to the media coverage his da’awah enjoys there. He trained numerous students who became great scholars and made significant impact in teaching Islamic education. Many literary works were written on his personality, reform movement and contributions and many academic researches were conducted on his activities.

The Sheikh has created awareness for Muslims to engage in public service, the military and other sectors of development in both public and private so that the ummah will be well represented. He also encourage the Muslims to actively participate in politics, join political parties, contest for elections and call on the generality of the Muslims to come out in mass during elections. It was on this issue he made the controversial statement of “Siyasa ta fi sallah”. The Sheikh was

182 Ibrahim, Muhammad Mansur , Ash-Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gummi: Hayatuhu, Mawaqifahu wa Ara’ahu, MA Dissertation, UDUS, 2000, p. 42 also instrumental to the formation of the first Muslim organization in the region, Jama’atu Nasril Islam, a development eventually lead to the formation of other religious organizations in the region. He has taught simple life, modesty and patiently listening and relating with his students; qualities that made him unique and role model for many scholars in the field of da’awah.

Impact of his time on his activities and fatwas

The Sheikh was born two decades after the British occupation of the Sokoto caliphate. Scholars and the Emirs after suffering defeat in the hands of the imperialists are managing with the little privileges given to them. The sheikh has once written to the Sultan about his Sallah message. His teacher Malam Junaid the Waziri of Sokoto wrote to the sheikh privately in Arabic language to advise him to consider the complexity of the time. He wrote, this is the time of silence and staying at home because whoever says the truth will die183. His courage in preaching against practices not in consistence with Shari’ah led to the issues he had with the authorities like the one in Maru which escalated to a regional issue and eventually led to his transfer.

Most of his fatwas are as a result of questions raised during his teaching sessions and they are recorded and many were published and its scope is general in nature and covers contemporary issues. He responds with precision to provide the answer and sometimes he go ahead to give reasons for his answer and in some occasions, he gives different opinions scholars had on the issue before deciding on the issue. This shows how he relates with people based on their background. A layman just needs an answer, a student will be given reason from the Qur’an and Hadith and advanced students will be referred to scholastic debate on the issue.

Maliki is the school majority of Muslims follow in the area and he bases his fatwas within the school. For instance, he up holds the school’s position on nullifying the fasting of a person who eats out of forgetfulness while he is fasting during Ramadan184. He also opined that, a person praying nafila should not lead others in farillah185. The Sheikh sometimes gives fatwas out of the Maliki position. For instance, he took position not in line with the known position of the Maliki school on issues like rising hands in going to ruku’ and raising from up it, the issue of reciting isti’azah and basmalah in prayer, eating horse and wife is not obliged to cook for the family, she should be served with cooked meals186. Despite his wealth of knowledge and experience, he is also used to telling his students I don’t know if he is not certain about an issue or he cannot find a legal provision to back his idea with.

A Review of the book “Where I Stand”

Where I stand is an autobiography that provides insight into the Sheikh’s journey from childhood to becoming a prominent teacher and scholar. The book explores his life as a Muslim scholar, his education, career as a public servant, his da’awah ordeals and the experiences from the

183 Gummi, A.M. and Tsiga I.A Where I Stand, 1994, p. 51 184 Ibrahim, Muhammad Mansur , Ash-Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gummi:Hayatuhu, Mawaqifahu wa Ara’ahu, p. 110 185 Ibrahim, Muhammad Mansur , Ash-Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gummi:Hayatuhu, Mawaqifahu wa Ara’ahu, p. 111 186 Ibrahim, Muhammad Mansur , Ash-Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gummi:Hayatuhu, Mawaqifahu wa Ara’ahu, p. 111

Nigerian Leaders and Elite. The book is divided in to thirteen chapters in two hundred and twenty pages in a reader friendly, clear and lucid manner. It contains some thought provoking ideas and also showed the depth of his knowledge not only in religious matters but also in other matters of human development. For instance, in chapter three, Judical Beginning, he lamented that many people among the elite tend not to see the destructive consequences of the British Colonialism due to the mental poisoning they suffer. This could be seen in their permanent dependence on the west and always bring foreign solution that conflict the values and needs of the people to solve local problems. The book contains tough decisions he took against associates and people in power while he was a judge. This is an inspiration for younger generation to uphold truth and justice. Citing examples of the cases he decided in court further shows the justness of his cause and he fears no any contradiction. In the field of da’awa, the book mentioned how the Sheikh always maintained study circle whenever he finds himself and focused on grooming students and training scholars. He maintained cordial relation with the authority and this led to many top government officials having more Islamic orientation; and the use of media in reaching out to people. The book also mentioned some instances of his ijtihad in solving emerging issues and this paper analyzed some of them to show his place as not only a teacher, public servant but also a mujtahid.

Ijtihad of Shaykh Abubakar Mahmud Gummi

The book under review despite being an autobiography, it has narrated some instances where the Sheikh used his personal ijtihad to provide rulings on some contemporary emerging issues in the context of the society in a practical and realistic manner. Some of these instances include: Circumcision in New Convert Adults Large contingent of Gwoza people converted to Islam, through the hard work of Waziri of Gwoza in 1962. Sardauna sent a team of few doctors and nurses who were to assist with the circumcision of the men. Sheikh Gummi when retuned back home from hajj was briefed by Sardaun himself about the development and the Sheikh explained that, it was wrong asking men to be circumcised. Although, it is recommended for men to be circumcised in Islam and it is not compulsory. At any rate, it is prohibited in the religion for anyone to see an adult’s private part, unless it is the person’s spouse. In the circumstance, therefore, if they wish they arrange convenient way for themselves and the doctors were recalled187. Changing the Will of a Deceased Burying Sardauna in Kaduna instead of Wurno where he left a Wasiyyah: after the demise of Sardauna, arrangements were made for his remains to be laid to rest and then information reached that the Sardaun had requested before he died that, he should be taken to Wurno and buried beside the grave of Sultan Muhammad Bello, his great-grandfather when he passes away. Sheikh explained that this wish could not be carried out. Sardauna was a martyr and in Islam, martyrs area always buried at the site of their death. During Uhud, the Prophet instructed that their remains of the martyrs should be taken back and buried where they were killed. The Sheikh led the funeral prayer of the late Sardauna and his wife in Kaduna and were buried there188.

187 Gummi, A.M. and Tsiga I.A Where I Stand, p. 105 188 Gummi, A.M. and Tsiga I.A Where I Stand, p. 113

When asked, where the tomb of Sardauda is in one of his teaching sessions, he said it was in his Kaduna house189. Sheikh admitted that, he is aware of the Sardauna’s will but the circumstances surrounding his death made him a martyr and he suggested to be buried where he died. He added that, there were attempts to fulfill the will by influential personalities like the former Nigerien Head of State Hamani Diori who came with the intention of removing the remains and taking it to Wurno but the Sheikh maintained his position and convinced them not to move him.190 Position of Concubines in Contemporary Period. Sheikh met some Emirs keeping slaves and concubines in their palaces and he opined it was impossible to justify keeping concubines in contemporary time in this country. The rule in Islam is that only in jihad could slaves be taken. But equally, if the Muslims were defeated during such a war, and a condition was imposed on them which they accepted, it would not be possible for them to break it afterwards. In the case of slavery in Nigeria, it was certainly agreed that it should be stopped after the British forces had defeated Muslims during the wars of colonial conquest. The emirs and some scholar claimed that, another agreement had been worked out with the colonial authorities three days after the first one had been signed. This time it was agreed that the emirs could retain the slaves serving in their palaces at the time and among whom were their selected concubines, although they should take no more191. Critical Analysis of the Ijtihad Circumcision in Islam Scholars are of the view that circumcision is wajib in Islam.192 It is one of the Fitrah193 and Ibrahim AS was commanded to circumcise himself at the age of 120 years194 and being millah of Ibrahim, we are commanded to follow his millah. (Nahl: 123). It was reported that the Prophet ﷺ said to a new convert: “remove the hair of disbelief and be circumcised”195. Furthermore, it involves cutting part of human and it will not be allowed unless it is compulsory and this is the position of Malik, Shafi’i and Ahmad and Malik added that aqlaf imamship and witness will not be accepted196. Some Sahabah and Tabi’un have warn seriously against skipping circumcision and there are reports indicating it affects some of his religious rites like purification, prayer, slaughter and testimonies and hajj. Some went to the extent of saying some of his act of worship

189 Funtuwa, Musa Lawal, Fatawar Abubakar Mahmud Gumi, Hudahuda, Zaria, vol. 2, p. 161, number 490 190 Funtuwa, Musa Lawal, Fatawar Abubakar Mahmud Gumi, p. 162. 191 Gummi, A.M. and Tsiga I.A Where I Stand, p.109 192 Ibn Qudamah, Abdullahi bn Ahmad, al-Mughni, Abdullahi bn Muhsin, ed, Dar Alim al-Kutub, Riyadh, 3rd edition, 1418, vol. 1, p.85 193 Bukhari, Muhammad bn Isma’il, Sahih Bukhari, vol. 5, p. 2209, Hadith 5550. 194 Bukhari, Muhammad bn Isma’il, Adabul Mufrad, Fu’ad Abdul Baqi, ed, Mat’aba Salafiyyah, Cairo, 1379, p. 428 Hadith 1250 its chain was graded as sahih by Albani 195 Abu Dawud, Suleiman bn Ash’ath, Sunan Abi Dawud, vol. 1, p. 267, Haditih 357. Shu’aib Arnaut said scholars said the Hadith is weak. 196 Ibn Qayyim, Muhammad bn Abubakar, Tuhfatul Maudud bi Ahkam Maulud, Dar Ata Ilm, Riyadh, 1440, p. 113 is not accepted until he get circumcised197. Circumcision is one of the major things that differentiate Muslims with non-Muslims.

Adult Circumcision

Hassan Basri said many people accepted Islam from among the Romans and Abyssinians and there are no reports that they were checked to make sure they were circumcised and there is no need for that198. This is because; the Arabs entirely are accustomed to circumcision, so also the Jews and some Christians. Those who accepted Islam got to know that it is a religious ritual and they continue observing it. And as for those uncircumcised, they go for it and if there is risk or threat to life ten it is not compulsory199.

Imam Ahmad differentiated between uncircumcised person born and raised in Islam and a convert and as for the convert; he has rukhsah unlike the Muslim who refused to do it200. The basis of this rukhsah was the unpleasant experience the scholars had about circumcising adult. It was reported that Amir of Basrah circumcised new converts during winter and some of them died. As mentioned earlier, many Romans and Abyssinians accepted Islam during the time of Prophet ﷺ time and no reports of confirmatory checks of their circumcision status201. On the basis of that, Imam Ahmad said it is not necessary.

Gwoza case: circumcision in rural in the 1960s has many issues to consider. Firstly, da’awah implication, as an area with non-Muslim majority, putting stringent condition before accepting Islam will make it difficult for some people. Health wise, there is threat to life and exposure to infections and other medical complication in the process. Economically, it affects their livelihood. Immerging circumcising villagers during rainy season, their stay to recover affects their farming and other business. Morally, keeping large number of adult naked for the period of recovery exposes them and this called for rethinking of taking proper arrangement to take care of all these case scenarios and this justifies the Sheikh’s decision to recall the doctors and stop the random circumcision of adult in the town.

Sheikh’s position could also be interpreted as, this is a religious rite that no clear command from the text that says adult converts should be circumcised as a matter of urgency and necessity and in this situation, the ruling could be readjusted and this was what prompted his ijtihad. The effect of adult circumcision would had on da’awa and smooth proselytization, health risk and moral breach, could necessitate readjusting the ruling to be optional for those who can endure, make personal and private arrangement for it; and for those who are afraid of taking the health risk, they are welcome to the fold of Islam and the ritual takes effect from the younger ones born in Islam and in this case the aqlaf will be eliminated gradually as they will be the last.

197 Ibn Asakir, Ali bn Hassan, Tabyin al-Imtinan bi Amr bil Ikhtitan, Dar Sahaba, Tanta, 1989, p. 33 Hadith 8 198 Bukhari, Muhammad bn Isma’il, Adabul Mufrad, p. 428 Hadith 1251 its chain was graded as sahih by Albani 199 Ibn Qayyim, Muhammad bn Abubakar, Tuhfatul Maudud bi Ahkam Maulud, p. 257

200 Ibn Qayyim, Muhammad bn Abubakar, Tuhfatul Maudud bi Ahkam Maulud, p.289 201 Bukhari, Muhammad bn Isma’il, Adabul Mufrad, p. 428 Hadith 1250

The Place for Burying a martyr and ruling of changing the deceased will

Burying martyrs where they died: martyrs where buried where they died and even if they were taken home, they should be brought back. Ibn Qayyim says the Sunnah is burying the martyrs on the battle field and on the spot of their death because; some people among the companions moved the remains of their relatives to Madina and the Prophet sent a message ordering them to return them to the battle ground and it became the tradition in burying martyrs202. Al-Waqidi added that Khalid al-Zuraqi was wounded at Yamamah and he later died of the sustained injury during Umar and Umar declared that, he is among Yamamah martyrs because he was wounded there203. Will to be buried in a particular place in Islam Shaikh Ibn Baz said it is allowed in Islam for a person to leave a wasiyyah to be buried in a certain place204. It is permissible for him to bequest that he be buried in such-and-such cemetery, or next to so-and-so person because; he may have an intention in doing so, such as being close to the righteous and good people, so it is permissible for him to be buried with the righteous and good people. But if it is not possible to carry it out, due to inability to do so, or due to distance, or something similar, then there is no need to carry it out, and he is buried in any of the Muslim cemeteries. There is no need for spending money from the estate to transport him as long as there is a Muslim cemetery and also the wasiyya limit of one third should not be exceeded205. Changing the will of the deceased in Islam: executing the will of the deceased is fulfilling promise and therefore compulsory and changing it without any reason is a serious offence. Allah says: “But whoever changes the will after hearing it, the blame will only be on those who made the change. Indeed, Allah is All-Hearing, All-Knowing” Baqara: 181. Ibn Kathir said who change wasiyya that is on ma’ruf has committed injustice and the of breaking the promise is on these who change the wasiyyah206.In a situation where the wasiyyah goes against Shari’ah, cost more than the one third of the estate or has additional burden the family cannot fulfill, it could not be considered as deliberate act and in this case there is no problem in changing as it considers the interest of the heirs.

Sardana as a martyr: a Muslim who is killed for unjust and illegal reasons with lethal weapon is considered as martyr. Anas said: the Prophet ﷺ ascended Mount Uhud with Abubakar, Umar and Uthman and it trembled beneath them. So the Prophet ﷺ said be still Uhud, for upon you are Prophet a truthful and two martyrs207. Umar and Uthman were assassinated by Abu Lu’lu’ and some rebels respectively and their death was regarded as martyrdom because it was prophesized by the Prophet even before it happened. Other scholars ruled that someone who died not in a regular warfare, they are washed and prayed over, but they could take the ruling

202Ibn al-Qayyim, Muhammad bn Abubakar, Zad al-Ma’ad fi Hadyi Khair al-Ibad, Shu’ab Arna’ut, ed, Mu’assasatu Risalah, Beirut, 1st edition, 1417, vol. 3, p. 249 203 Waqidi, Muhammad bn Umar, Maghazi, Dar al-A’lami, Beirut, 1989, vol. 1, p. 345 204Bin Baz, Hukmu al-Wasiyyah bi Dafni fi Makanin Mu’ayyan wa Hukmu Tanfiziha, accessed at https://binbaz.org.sa/fatwas/13986/ on 25/12/2025 205 Bin Baz, Hukmu al-Wasiyyah bi Dafni fi Makanin Mu’ayyan wa Hukmu Tanfiziha, 206Ibn kathir, Isma’il bn Umar, Tafsir Qur’an al-Azim, Samin bn Muhammad, Dar Taybah, Riyadh, 2nd edition, vol. 1 p. 496 207 Bukhari, Muhammad bn Isma’il, Sahih Bukhari, vol. 3, p. 1344, Hadith 3472 of a martyr in the hereafter since they were unjustly killed. On the basis of this and considering the gruesome manner the enemy killed sardauna, we come to agreement that he is a martyr.

Ijtihad of sheikh: Sardauna is a martyr and therefore the sunnah to be buried in the place he died. On the other hand, there is existing will and sunnah supersedes personal wasiyyah. There are other issues like, security concern. For people of Sokoto to see the body of one of their illustrious son, royal family and the whole Premier in that situation may lead to break of law and order and can cause reprisals attacks on innocent non indigenes which will further escalate and worsen the situation. It may also lead to delay in the burial which is supposed to be done within the shortest possible time. Moving the dead body to another place for burial is allowed in Islam if there is maslaha of taking him closer to his people or a person who will attract prayer for him provided it could be done before the corpse decomposes. In this situation, changing the will was more convenient and security wise the best.

Concubines in Contemporary Period

Slavery in Northern Nigeria: slavery is phenomena that existed in all parts of the world. Northern Nigeria has high concentration of slaves acquired through tributes, raids and trade and were engaged in household activities, manufacturing activities such as cotton coding, thread spinning and dying; livestock keeping, trade, agric and the military208. The Jihad in the region made slavery more organized and align it with Shari’ah and as a result, many were freed and given the right of guardianship under the institution of al-wala’ many females were freed and assimilated into marriage and concubinage. Slave children whose master accepted paternity are automatically freed.

The British after the conquest of the area proclaimed the so called abolishment of slavery and emancipation of all slaves. This made enslavement illegal and Lugard criminalized trade in slaves so that it will naturally die209. The slaves were given choice to follow their inclination, some women were married off and for the minors, and freed slaves homes were established. Lugard made the abolishing in phases, proclaimed any child born after March 1901 is automatically free, slaves who deserted their masters should not be forcibly returned to the masters. And due to his indirect rule trick, he promised not to interfere with existing domestic slaves who chose to remain with rulers and their concubines and these concessions to the rulers made his policies contradictory.

Having concubines in the present time: the emirs continued keeping slaves and concubines as maids in the palace and the practice continued up to the time when Sheikh brought the issue of legality or otherwise of having slaves and concubines in the contemporary period. He argued that, it is quite illegal for anybody to contemplate keeping concubines in the present time. Even if such an agreement had been reached with the colonial master three days after the first one had been signed, it was totally unacceptable. In Islam, if a slave was pronounced free once, he could not possible be enslaved again.

208Abdulwasiu Ajimobi Abdurrahman, A history of freed slaves’ home in Northern Nigeria 1900-1926, PhD thesis submitted to the department of history, The University of Mississippi, 2022, P 26 209 Abdulwasiu Ajimobi Abdurrahman, A history of freed slaves’ home in Northern Nigeria, P 26

The issue is quite intricate. Firstly, the emirs claimed to have had agreement with the colonial masters to allow them continue keeping their slaves as maids. Secondly, the colonial master just abolished slavery without any arrangement of repatriating the slaves to their family and no social security that follow their separation with their masters as against the provision of wala’ in Shari’ah which the Prophet ﷺ says is for the emancipator ( أعتق لمن الوالء)210. This may also make some slaves to prefer remaining under their masters than having freedom with nowhere to go and latter be subjected to taxations. The arguments of the Sheikh were based on the fact that, the agreement after defeat is void and taking slaves back to slavery after emancipation is not allowed in Shariah and on the basis of these, he ruled out the legality of having concubines in the contemporary period.

Conclusion

The nature of the region calls for native scholars to actively engage themselves in providing solutions to domestic emerging issues. Scholars of the region have shown capacity in handling such issues and respond to them in a practical manner. The Sheikh is a reformer and mujtahid who made ijtihad in determining legal position of peculiar issues. Mujtihad in Shari’ah has been given waiver in case he missed the ruling when conducting Ijtihad and he will be given one reward for his ijtihad and if he gets the ruling, he will be given two rewards for the ijtihad and for getting it done rightly as mentioned in the Hadith of Amr bn Ass as reported by Imam Bukhari211. As a product of personal judgment, if another person come up with another verdict, it is a known rule among scholars that, ijtihad do not invalidate another ijtihad. Recommendation The paper recommends further studies on the manuscripts of the Sheikh, compilation and digitalization of his audio records as most of them were recorded in materials that need to be modernized. The paper also recommends the Ijtihad of the Shaykh be put together in one place for further analysis on his methodology.

BIBLIOGRAPHY Abdulwasiu Ajimobi Abdurrahman, A history of freed slaves’ home in Northern Nigeria 1900- 1926, PhD thesis submitted to the department of history, The University of Mississippi, 2022 Abu Dawud, Suleiman bn Ash’ath, Sunan Abi Dawud, Shu’aib Arna’ut, ed, Dar Risalah Alamiyyah, 1st edition, 1430. Bin Baz, Hukmu al-Wasiyyah bi Dafni fi Makanin Mu’ayyan wa Hukmu Tanfiziha, accessed at https://binbaz.org.sa/fatwas/13986/ on 25/12/2025 Bukhari, Muhammad bn Isma’il, Adabul Mufrad, Fu’ad Abdul Baqi, ed, Mat’aba Salafiyyah, Cairo, 1379.

210 Bukhari, Muhammad bn Isma’il, Sahih Bukhari, vol. 1, p. 174, Hadith 444 211 Bukhari, Muhammad bn Isma’il, Sahih Bukhari, vol. 6, p. 2676, Hadith 6919

Bukhari, Muhammad bn Isma’il, Sahih Bukhari, edited by Mustapha Diban, Dar Ibn Kathir, Damascus, 1443. Funtuwa, Musa Lawal, Fatawar Abubakar Mahmud Gumi, Hudahuda, Zaria. Ghazali, Muhammad bn Muhammad, al-Mustasfa, Muhammad Abus Salam , ed, Dar Kutub Ilmiyyah, Beirut, 1st edition, 1993. Gummi, A.M. and Tsiga I.A, Where I Stand, Ibadan, 1994. Ibn al-Qayyim, Muhammad bn Abubakar, Zad al-Ma’ad fi Hadyi Khair al-Ibad, Shu’ab Arna’ut, ed, Mu’assasatu Risalah, Beirut, 1st edition, 1417 . Ibn Asakir, Ali bn Hassan, Tabyin al-Imtinan bi Amr bil Ikhtitan, Dar Sahaba, Tanta, 1989 . Ibn Athir, Mubarak bn Muhammad, al-Nihayah fi Gharib al-Hadith wal-Athar, Tahir Ahmad, ed, Maktabah Ilmiyyah, Beirut, 1399. Ibn kathir, Isma’il bn Umar, Tafsir Qur’an al-Azim, Samin bn Muhammad, Dar Taybah, Riyadh, 2nd edition. Ibn Manzur, Muhammad bn Mukrim, Lisanul Arab, Dar Sadir, Beirut, 2nd edition, 1414. Ibn Qayyim, Muhammad bn Abubakar, Tuhfatul Maudud bi Ahkam Maulud, Dar Ata Ilm, Riyadh, 1440. Ibn Qudamah, Abdullahi bn Ahmad, al-Mughni, Abdullahi bn Muhsin, ed, Dar Alim al-Kutub, Riyadh, 3rd edition, 1418. Ibrahim, Muahammad Yusri, Fiqh Nawazil lil Aqalliyat al-Muslimah, Dar al-Yusi, Cairo, 1st edition, 1434. Ibrahim, Muhammad Mansur , Ash-Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gummi: Hayatuhu, Mawaqifahu wa Ara’ahu, MA Dissertation, UDUS, 2000. Ibrahim, Mustapha, et al, Mu’jam al-Wasit, Mu’jam Lughah al-Arabiyyah, Cairo, 2nd edition, 1392. Jangebe, Huzaifa Aliyu, Islamic Reform in Nigeria: The Contribution of Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi, International Journal of Humanities and Social Science, Vol. 5, No. 9, 2015. Juwaini, Abdul Malik bn Abdullahi, Waraqat , Abdul Latif Muahmmad, ed, np, 1431. Waqidi, Muhammad bn Umar, Maghazi, Dar al-A’lami, Beirut, 1989.