Introduction
Contemporary Nigeria has witnessed the emergence of hundreds of Muslim scholars with different educational backgrounds, diverse ideological leanings and varying degrees of influence. While some scholars rose and reached the peak of intellectual careers amidst hundreds of their peers with similar feats and reputations, others transcended that level and stood out to, besides knowledge transmission, assume the role of reformers whose missions permeated multidimensional facets of life, culminating in the massive transformation of the society. The career of Shaykh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi coincided with the era the British colonial administrators were erecting the necessary bureaucratic edifices in the educational, political and judicial sectors, which their successors continued after independence in 1960. A considerable amount of Gumi’s years was spent in the service of Nigeria both before and after the departure of colonial government. Gumi’s times were full of significant turning points that shaped religious and sociopolitical dynamics of northern Nigeria, leaving behind a legacy that is still celebrated and cherished by a section of Muslims on one hand and on the other hand disliked and undermined by some others.
This paper appraises Gumi’s scholarly career, touching on the trajectories and phases of his intellectual developments, starting from his family circle and up to the various places he visited and the sojourns he embarked upon within and outside Nigeria. It reviews the significant terminals and landmarks that may have motivated his followers and admirers to revere him and adhere to his teachings, which may similarly be the source of disenchantment with his mission by others. The paper further examines Gumi’s autobiography Where I Stand while juxtaposing it against Islam is Moderation, another personal life history authored by a relatively younger scholar compared to Gumi but also the latter’s long-time critics. It draws on multiple sources including other works and literature produced on Gumi.
Numerous studies and works have surveyed the transformations of religion and Islamic society in colonial and postcolonial northern Nigeria, with a particular emphasis on the emergence of new scholars, Islamic trends and movements which have pursued the cause of reform and perhaps challenged the old, syncretic order, thus frustrating the hegemonic authority of the hitherto dominant Islamic traditions in the region. Most of the works look at the developments that were witnessed in colonial and postcolonial northern Nigeria, which affected the Sufi brotherhoods – the Qadiriyyah and Tijjaniyyah orders and the ritual, structural and political changes and adjustments that were made to them, courtesy of the connections, influence and efforts of their leaders.11While the scope of some of these works does not cover Gumi’s contributions, a significant number of other literature reserves considerable portions to discuss Gumi’s career and mission and their impacts on northern Nigerian Muslims.12While some studies have assessed his scholarly contributions13, hardly a writing of abook size, academic thesis or
11 See John N. Paden, Religion and Political Culture in Kano (London and Berkley: University of California Press, 1973). 12 Roman Loimeir, Islamic Reform and Political Change in Northern Nigeria (Evanston: Northwestern University Press, 1997). 13 Huzaifa Aliyu Jangebe, “Islamic Reform in Nigeria: The Contribution of Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi”,International Journal of Humanities and Social Science, Vol. 5, No. 9; September 2015.
journal article14 would examine the evolution of Izala15 or the growth of Salafism16 in Nigeria without laying a background with Gumi’s ideas and his intrepid contestation of Sufism. Similarly, works on the trends and development of Hausa (both oral and published) tafsir have made copious references to Gumi’s aired interpretation of Qur’an on Radio Nigeria Kaduna17and his exegetical magnum opus, Radd al-Adh’han Ila Ma’an Al-Qur’an.18
The paper is divided into six segments including introduction and conclusion. After the introductory section, it surveys the early life and education of Gumi, looking at the religious sciences he acquired at his home within the school run by his father, before he reached out to other scholars, including after registering at formal schools which took him to many places outside his birth place but also out of his native country as an advanced student. The third segment examines the career of Gumi as a scribe to Chief Alkali of Sokoto, as a teacher – a position that enhanced his worldview and opened his eyes to other intellectual opportunities, but also his appointment as a Deputy Grand Khadi and later as substantive Grand Khadi of Northern Nigeria, becoming the first indigenous person to hold the post in the region. It similarly recounts his preaching and scholarly efforts which manifested in the religious lessons he presented at various places since his days as a senior student in one of the schools he attended. The next segment highlights some important landmarks in Gumi’s life, focusing on his engagements with key Nigerian actors, his international outings and the role he played in pan-Islamic development across the globe, his major thoughts and ideas on un-Islamic beliefs and practices, his contribution towards the creation of strategic religious organizations and other notable spheres in his career. The last section before the conclusion comparatively analyzes the meeting and parting points between Gumi’s Where I Standand Shaykh Ibrahim Salih al-Husayni’s Islam is Moderation.
Birth, Early Life & Education
Like many acclaimed scholars, Gumi descended from a family that was committed to dissemination of Islamic knowledge. His father Mallam Mahmud Na-Gumi, whose ancestry is traceable to Arab Bedouins who wandered around Hausa land, centuries before the establishment of Sokoto Caliphate, was one of the most respected scholars in areas covered by today’s Zamfara, Sokoto and Kebbi states. He served as a Khadi (a judge of Islamic court) and this was one of the factors that earned him and the family at large prominence and prestige within the neighbourhood. Gumi’s father had a tendency of walking the talk such that he did not merely teach and preach but also tried to put his assertions in actions. This had a profound
14Andrea Brigaglia, “The Volatility of Salafi Political Theology, the War on Terror and the Genesis of Boko Haram”, 2015, Diritto e questioni pubbliche, Palermo. 15 See Ousmane Kane, Muslim Modernity in Postcolonial Nigeria: A Study on the Society for the Removal of Innovation and Reinstatement of Tradition (Leiden, Boston: Brill, 2003) & Ramzi Ben Amara, The Izala Movement in Nigeria: Genesis, Fragmentation and Revival (Germany: Göttingen University Press, 2020). 16 Alexander Thurston, Salafism in Nigeria: Islam Preaching and Politics (Cambridge University Press, 2016). 17 Usman Sani Abbas, “Trends of Tafsīr among Selected ‘Ulamā’ in Northern Nigeria” PhD Thesis, (Kano: Bayero University, Kano, 2005). 18 Andrea Brigaglia, "Two Published Hausa Translations of the Qur'ān and their Doctrinal Background", Journal of Religion in Africa 35, 4 (2005): 424-449, doi: https://doi.org/10.1163/157006605774832225.
influence on his son, later to become one of the most respected scholars whose mission and career started during colonial period and reached its peak after independence.
Abubakar Mahmud Gumi was born on November 7, 1924. He acquired some of the basic Islamic sciences from the teaching circle led by his father, which was attended and equally coordinated by other senior students from within and outside the Gumi vicinity. Whenever Gumi’s father was away for his official function and even when he was around, his school would be run by his senior disciples who taught junior and younger students. It was one of these senior disciples, Mallam Musa Ambursa that took young Gumi to his hometown, Ambursa, a few miles away from Gumi, for a vacation where he continued to teach Gumi who was by then not more than six years old. Gumi keenly narrates his experiences in Ambursa and how, despite being under the custody of one of his father’s disciples, he joined other pupils who went round the community to beg for food. As opposed to what obtains today, begging as at then was, in the words of Gumi, encouraged and considered as a way of inculcating modesty and “instilling humility and discipline among the pupils”.19At any rate, Gumi spent three months with Mallam Musa and since his father neither wanted nor allowed his children to beg, Gumi might not in the years to come have had similar experiences which he had in Ambursa.
As Gumi grew up, he was in 1933 enrolled into the Elementary School situated at Dogon Daji within Sokoto Province, which was his first contact with western education, brought and supervised by the British Colonial administration. Since Gumi was already exposed to some basic Arabic literacy at his father’s informal Islamic school, he did not find English literacy very difficult and soon he mastered alphabet and was far ahead of his peers in religious learning. That was why he was obviously appointed as Religion Prefect and was liked and held with esteem by most of his teachers and colleagues. Due to certain strategic reasons, before Gumi and his colleagues finished, a decision was reached by education authority to open a new school in Sokoto called Central Elementary School and students were transferred there.After spending a year, Gumi completed his elementary education and was admitted to Sokoto Middle School (SMS) in 1936, barely a year before his father’s death. He spent six years and graduated in 1942, a year after he married at the age of 17. Given his religious background, he served as an Imam. Similarly, while undergoing his formal schooling, he also used his spare time to continue with his religious education under different scholars and in this process he learned several classical books such as Risala, Mukhtasar, Askari, Mu’allaqat al-Sittah and Maqamat al-Hariri under Mallam Shehu Yabo while he was taught Alfiyyat bin Malik, the Arabic masterpiece of grammatical ode by one Mallam Junaydu. Mallam Bashir Sokoto, a teacher at the SMS taught students including Gumi religious poetry. Gumi unveils that due to penury he copied most of these books with his hand and used the handwritten copies for his study.20
Gumi proceeded to Kaduna College for his higher studies but because he wanted to pursue his career as religious educationist, an aspiration that he thought he would not adequately meet at the Kaduna College, he decided to switch to the newly established Law School in Kano. But because his formal background showed that he attended Middle School, he was regarded as unqualified to proceed to the Law School until after undergoing a one-year remedial course at
19 Sheikh Abubakar Gumi with Ismail A. Tsiga, Where I Stand (Ibadan: Spectrum Books Limited, 1992), 10. 20 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand,17-21.
Khadi School in Sokoto in 1942. The school was rather informal and Gumi had studied various books on Islamic jurisprudence, after which he joined the Northern Provinces Law School in Kano. It seemed that he enjoyed his times in this school as it not only met his academic aspirations, but it also purveyed him with an autonomous atmosphere that encouraged free interaction to challenge, debate and argue with teachers, a remarkable shift in northern Nigeria’s learning traditions.21
Apart from normal Islamic learning, the process Gumi passed through within his intellectual home headed by his father, he was also trained and brought up according to moral etiquettes entrenched in the socio-religious traditions of Muslim family institutions. It can be seen from the above that Gumi emerged as a hybridized figure who combined Islamic scholarship and western education, representing a radical departure of knowledge acquisition in Hausaland. He mastered much of the sciences that qualified one to become as scholar and it was this background that influenced his decision to lean towards a specialization in modern education that was more compatible with his family background, making him one of the pioneers of legal profession in post-independence Nigeria.
A Career in Civil Service& as an Islamic Scholar
After graduating from Law School in Kano in 1947, Gumi was posted as a scribe to the Office of Chief Alkali, Sokoto Province. This post was equivalent to the position of registrar whose functions include filing complaints of disputants and documenting court proceedings. Gumi’s stint as scribe, which spanned only a year, had introduced him to the real judicial world and he must have gained much experience that would aid his career the judiciary. It was within this period also that he began conducting tafsir in Sokoto, which was abruptly interrupted by his transfer to Kano to teach at Law School in Kano. Soon he was identified by students who trooped to his lodge to learn various Islamic disciplines in an informal atmosphere. Meanwhile, it was not destined that he would stay long at the Law School and he was transferred to the newly established Elementary Training Centre (ETC) in Maru, located 27 miles away from Gusau in Sokoto Province. He taught Arabic and Islamic Studies as well as Mathematics. Gumi served as an Imam at ETC and he used his position to explain religious matters for a brief moment after prayer. In no time, students started trooping to Gumi’s house to learn and within short time a thriving community of scholars was established as Gumi taught Islamic books, which culminated into evening ilmi school, with some learners coming to settle as boarders purposely to learn.22
It was in Maru that Gumi met Mallam Aminu Kano who also taught at the school. It was also in Maru that he espoused some of his critical views that foregrounded his zeal and inclination towards disagreeing with whatever he believed was religiously wrong, even if that would be against the wishes of his superiors or authorities. According to Gumi, commanding the good and prohibiting the bad (al-Amr bi al-Ma’ruf wa al-Nahy an al-Munkar), was an obligation and no matter what, once he saw that something was observed in the breach, he won’t hesitate to offer correction. Gumi was backed by Aminu Kano to articulate his objections against some developments and issues such as the award of medals and honors given by the British Kingdom to emirs who in the eyes of Gumi and Aminu Kano were symbols of Islam and ought to preserve
21 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 27-33. 22 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 36-46.
its orthodoxy and purity. Similarly, with active support of Aminu Kano, Gumi protested the habit of Chief Imam of Maru who, instead of using water to perform ablution, was fond of making dry ablution (tayammum) before leading congregants in prayer, which Gumi saw as a heinous aberration from the universal norm known in Islamic jurisprudence. All these intrepid moves would have proven extremely suicidal to the career of Gumi, but perhaps because he emerged out of them triumphant, he became more determined to speak what he considered as truth and be adamant to defend it at all cost.
In 1950 Gumi went back to Kano for a two-year course at School for Arabic Studies (SAS) to qualify for Higher Elementary Centre Examination. During this period, he underwent the training while also teaching. After successful completion, he was retained to teach on secondment, and afterwards he was absorbed into the services of the Northern Region Ministry of Education.23In 1953 he secured a scholarship to study at Bakht al-Ruda Institute in Sudan alongside colleagues like Shehu Galadanci, Halliru Binji, Abdulkadir Okereke, Bibi Faruk, and Hassan Gwarzo. They studied Arabic, History, Maths, English & Drawing at the end of which they were granted Advanced Diploma in Education and they returned to Nigeria in 1956.Upon return from Sudan, Gumi developed interest to change profession and he therefore applied for the post of Islamic programs officer at Nigerian Broadcasting Corporation, but he was not selected, obviously because the Ministry of Education did not want to release him. Instead, as a way of compensation and consolation, he was promoted to the rank of Senior Education Officer at the S.A.S, but within a year, he was again seconded as Pilgrims Officer on request from the Federal Public Service and posted to Jeddah.24
After spending nine months in Jeddah for the above assignment which, it seemed, met the expectations of his employers, Gumi returned to Nigeria. The Premier of Northern Region, Ahmadu Bello (Sardauna), whom Gumi already knew more than a decade earlier and who sided with Gumi in the latter’s altercations with prominent figures during his days in Maru25, offered to appoint him as Ambassador to Saudi Arabia, but he declined and preferred to resume to his teaching career at S.A.S. In 1960 as the country headed for independence, Gumi applied for a judicial job and he was successfully appointed as Deputy Grand Khadi,26 reflecting his early experience as a scribe to the Chief Alkali of Sokoto Province. Gumi served in this post for two years and he was promoted to the rank of Grand Khadi, becoming the first indigenous officer to reach the apex of northern Nigeria’s judicial cadre. This milestone marked a significant landmark in Gumi’s profession, but it was just one of the facets of achievements and turning points in his career as a civil servant and an Islamic scholar.
Significant Landmarks in Gumi’s Mission
As mentioned earlier, Gumi enjoined the backing of Sardauna since the former’s days in Maru when the latter served as secretary of the Emirate Council and head of Native Administration in Sokoto. This relationship continued to flourish and grew to the point that Gumi became Sardauna’s religious advisor and one of his best confidants. The duos had admittedly made impact on each other’s life, but it was Gumi who survived to relate most of the dimensions of
23 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 63. 24 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 65-69. 25 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 50-51. 26 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 71-74.
their interactions. It was Gumi who advised Sardauna to invest in religion and to expand his networks of activities to have a greater inclusion of religious matters at domestic and global levels. This manifested in Sardauna’s foreign tours to most of Muslim countries such as Niger, Guinea, Senegal, Gambia, Morocco, Algeria, Libya, Tunisia, Yemen, Iraq, Kuwait, Sudan, Pakistan, Iran, Lebanon, UAE, Jordan, etc.Gumi not only accompanied Sardauna in these trips but he also acted as his interpreter and strategic link with Islamic institutions. The development culminated in the establishment of Muslim World League (MWL), with Sardauna, who initially proposed the idea, being elected as MWL’s vice president. Gumi became Sardauna’s representative and he was subsequently absolved as a full member of the league.27
One of the legacies left behind by the Gumi-Sardauna alliance, apart from enhancing Gumi’s civil prestige and public prominence which continued to play out throughout Gumi’s lifetime, was the construction of Sultan Bello Mosque in Kaduna in 1963 and it was singlehandedly financed by Sardauna. The mosque became an important centre and strategic public medium for Gumi to disseminate his message and enhance his missionary career.It was situated near the residence of Sardauna and not too far from the Sultan’s palace in Kaduna. The Premier himself, ministers, top government officials and senior civil servants frequented the mosque to listen to Gumi’s preaching.28 The tafsir which Gumi conducted in the mosque attracted big audience and although he initially rejected the request to get it aired on the radio, he eventually gave up and with that, his network of listenership significantly increased.29 This was how Gumi’s preaching created a bridge that brought western educated elites (‘yan boko) and those trained in traditional Islamic system together30. Be that as it may, Sardauna-Gumi relationship remained cordial, and even after the assassination of Sardauna in 1966, Gumi vehemently defended what his benefactor had lived and died for, including on the face of the leader of the coup that led to the death of the Premier.
Another lasting legacy bequeathed by this relationship is Jama’atu Nasril Islam(JNI), with Gumi giving out his house in Kaduna to serve as the organization’s headquarters.31Gumi spoke favourably with respect to other Nigerian leaders with whom he had close interactions, particularly Balewa, Gowon, Murtala, Shehu ‘Yar’adua, Shagari, Babangida and Sultan Ibrahim Dasuki while both Aguiyi Ironsi and Buhari seemed to be in his bad book. Murtala established Federal Sharia Court of Appeal, which Gumi as a seasoned judicial expert, had longed for, but to the dismay of Muslims, was not sustained after Murtala’s murder.32Contrary to the conviction of some people that reform must take effect from the bottom, Gumi firmly believed that “the best way to effect change in any society is to educate those who have power, about the virtues of God, justice and the fear of God. If they could accept to do good and carry out the demands of their office in conformity with the wishes of God, there would always be peace and happiness in the society”.33Gumi’s philosophy was that if members of the top ladder of the society know
27 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 99-104. 28 Ben Amara, “The Izala Movement in Nigeria”, 116-117. 29 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 129-130. 30 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 38. 31 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 106. 32 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 206. 33 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 130.
and accept the truth, it is easier for the masses to follow suit. But if it is the reverse, many conflicts would ensue.34
In his autobiography, Gumi is tactically silent about his affiliation to any religious group or Sufi order, but some sources indicate that it was in the 1940s that he “renounced his affiliation to the Qadiriyya order”.35 Gumi might have been directly or indirectly associated with Qadiriyya which he renounced, as argued by the source above. Meanwhile, it was also probable that the source interprets Gumi’s decision to study Tahir Feromma’sNazm al-Kubra under the Qadiriyya leader Shaykh Nasiru Kabara as being inspired by his identification with the order. Whatever the case may be, Gumi is portrayed as the first indigenous person to publicly challenge Sufism and turuq in the history of Nigeria.36 He argued that Sufi teachings are contradictory to Islam particularly the claims that Sufi leaders possess extraordinary powers, the alleged physical meeting with the Prophet by Sufi figures, drum or bandir beating, the excessive virtue of Salatul Fatih and aberrational views articulated in Jawahir al-Ma’ani, tarbiyya and other unfounded beliefs and irreligious practices. Gumi also disagreed with the notion of withdrawal from the society which he alleged Sufism advocates; he reasoned that it is incompatible with the goal of building an Islamic state.37However, he exonerated both Jilani and Tijjani, concluding that views ascribed to them were baseless. Gumi further accused Sufi Shaykhs of extorting their followers to the point of sacrificing their wealth to the service and comfort of their Shaykhs and to the detriment of their dependents, all in a hope to get saved from predicaments and difficulties as promised by the “parasitic” Shaykhs.38
He also refuted certain traditional beliefs and practices such as genuflecting to greet elders and attitudes towards spirits and ancestors, natural objects like trees, rocks and rivers which were, according to him, believed to have supernatural powers typical of pre-Islamic days.Animals were slaughtered as a sacrifice to them in order to seek their assistance. Gumi emphasized that these practices were shirk (polytheism) and not in tune with the correct Islamic belief. Gumi resorted to using writing medium to publicize much of his intellectual views against Sufism. In 1972, Gumi published his al-Aqidah al-Sahihah bi Muwafaqat al-Shari’ahand in the late 1970s he began publishing articles in Gaskiya Ta Fi Kwabo, which elicited terse controversy and hostility in Nigerian Sufi circles.
In general, Gumi did not seem to acknowledge the validity of Tasawwuf because according to him, neither the Prophet (SAW) nor his companions taught Sufism. In fact, Gumi had an impression that Sufism was promoted by enemies of Islam.39Gumi’s views appear to be contestable even among the Salafis, and he himself at times made assertions that at least reduced the weight and heinousness of his strident and generalized condemnations of Sufism, as will be shown shortly.It should be mentioned that Gumi’s attack did not go unchallenged and in this process, several ways were used to halt his mission. He narrates that attempts were made to assassinate him on several occasions, including through poisoning.Gumi’s teachings inspired
34 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 136. 35 Thurston, Salafism in Nigeria, 83. 36 Loimeier, Islamic Reform, 17. 37 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 36. 38 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 133-150. 39 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 166-167.
the founding of Jama’atu Izalatil Bid’ah Wa Iqamatus Sunnah (JIBWIS) which in the following decades launched the most vociferous intellectual attacks on tariqa, a development that radically changed the order of things and forged a shift of ideological identities that crafted a space for Salafis within the sphere of northern Nigeria’s religious composition.
Mallam Ismaila Idris, a diehard follower of Gumi and a fearless fellow was the person who through the IBWIS platform he cofounded publicized Gumi’s views and extended it beyond the circle they were initially confined in. As interreligious relations were strained and things deteriorated and almost went out of control due to Gumi’s teachings which Sufis found scathing and their impatience and insistence to silence him even if through violent means, peace meetings were multiply convened to foster harmony and tackle the perilously growing sectarian strife. Gumi alleged that turuq leaders had violated the resolutions reached during the meetings, while the turuq leaders also accused him of reneging on the promises each party made during the pacts. One heavy recommendation offered by Gumi which, by the way, seemed infeasible, was that all religious groups and movements be abolished so that Muslims would set aside their sectarian affiliations and unite under the umbrella of Qur’an and Sunnah.40
Despite the extremely nonconformist picture of Gumi painted above regarding Sufism and affiliation to turuq, to the point that some may have concluded that he excommunicated adherents of Sufi orders, another broader glance at his worldview and mission suggests otherwise. Gumi boldly argues that committing a sin (including a practice that may be deemed irreligious) does not make one an unbeliever(kafir), except if one falsifies or rubbishes the Islamic stipulation that forbids the sin.41He maintained that he never declared any tariqa adherent as unbeliever, but rather he outlined offences and explained “that whoever committed them had gone against the laws of Islam”.42Instead of bureaucrats and former public officers who used to dominate the National Pilgrims Board as members, with Gumi as chairman since the regime of Gowon, when he was retained to be the chairman by the Obasanjo military administration, Gumi recommended that Sufi scholars be invited and appointed into the board’s membership.43
Moreover, Shaykh Usman Danfodio, one of the four African scholars Gumi upheld as his role models was a Qadiri and an acclaimed reformer. Gumi recognized the erudition of Mallam Nasiru Kabara from whom he learned Nazm al-Kubra44, just as he acknowledged the uprightness, patriotism and scholarly authority of other key Sufi icons such as Mallam Rabi’u Dan Tinki, the father of Isyaku Rabi’u, a leader of Tijjaniyya in West Africa45; Muhammad Sanusi, the deposed emir of Kano and a representative of Shaykh Ibrahim Inyass46; and to some extent, Shaykh Ibrahim Salih al-Husainy.47 The latter’s Islam is Moderationjoins a lot of issues with and provides counter-narratives of many of Gumi’s views and achievements as will be examined shortly.By
40 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 167. 41 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand,138. 42 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 164. 43 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 163. 44 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 87. 45 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 33. 46 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 87. 47 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 171.
claimingthat Sunnis constituted 80 percent of the world Muslim population, Gumi could never evade accommodating Sufisin this broad religious umbrella.48
Encounter between Where I Stand and Islam is Moderation
Whereas Where I Stand supplies the life history of Gumi who died in 1992, less than a month after it was completed, Islam is Moderation is a rendition of the autobiography of Shaykh Ibrahim Salih al-Husayni, born in 1938. Al-Husayni is younger than Gumi by almost a decade and a half, but they were yet brought together with others as counterparts by many occasions as scholars and religious leaders representing the majority of Nigerian Muslims. Both autobiographies were penned with the assistance of esteemed scholars and university academics who have made reputation as prolific writers among northern Nigeria’s intelligentsia. In Islam is Moderation, al-Husayni recounts most of the significant details about his family and ancestral backgrounds, his lineal connection – from both paternal and maternal sides – to the Prophet (SAW) through the latter’s two grandsons, al-Hasan and al-Husayn, his birth, early life, and growth. He also relates the trajectories and terminals of his knowledge acquisition especially the countless sojourns he undertook in Nigeria and beyond and the various teachers he studied with or met for the purpose of certification. The book unveils the dimensions of al-Husayni’s thoughts and ideas, positions and perceptions concerning Islamic faith and belief, worship and jurisprudence, education, intra and interreligious relations, Nigeria’s socio-political developments, geopolitics, religiosity and secularism, Islamic law (Shari’ah), among other important subjects and issues. In a fashion very much similar to Gumi’s approach but with a high degree of assertive tone, reflecting how well established and authoritative he is as an accomplished scholar, al-Husayni chronicles his interactions with prominent and key political actors and institutions in Nigeria and other parts of the Islamic world, emphasizing the respect and recognition he earned in all of those spaces.
Islam is Moderation appears to have been preconceived to parallel Where I Stand in much more ways. Like Gumi, al-Husayni delves deep into the intricate interplay between the religion and politics and the attitudes of some leaders and politicians towards Islam. He also recollects interactions among scholars and religious leaders belonging to different sectarian persuasions, while in some instances assessing the worldviews and intellectual weights of the scholars. Besides elaborate discussion on international politics and global developments of the 20th century which spilled to the 21st century, al-Husayni (in the same fashion with Gumi) also plunges into comparative religion with a focus on Christianity and Nigerian Christians, noting the crises that broke out between them and Muslims in some areas within northern Nigeria, warning Christians of their excesses, intolerance and disrespectful behaviour towards Islam.49Interestingly, Gumi reveals that during one of these ethno-religious crises that erupted in Kaduna, a group of terrified Igbo took refuge in his house until after sanity was restored.50
Al-Husayni’s book portrays him as a tolerant, moderate scholar who pursues the cause of unity and peaceful coexistence amidst the growing tensions that often characterize relations of Muslims of varying denominations. Despite his engagement in Tasawwuf, he does not approve
48 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 183. 49Shaykh Ibrahim Salih al-Husayni with Auwalu Anwar, Islam is Moderation (Ibadan: Safari Books Ltd., 2021), 324-326. 50 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 124.
of aberrations and esoteric articulations of Sufi fellows that mar the distinction of Shari’ah and tend to reinterpret or even dislodge the relevance and implication of textual stipulations in favour of complex philosophical views of certain Sufi saints or figures.Al-Husayni makes explicit declarations that he owes no loyalty to whatever lacks basis in the Qur’an and Sunnah, arguing that Ilm al-Batin and Ilm al-Haqiqah, the philosophical framework around which Tasawwuf revolves, have been corrupted and destroyed.51It is in line with this that he not onlyadmits that there are “errors” in the books that serve as references for the views of Tijjaniyya,52 the Sufi order he identifies with but he also endorses the death sentence that was passedto and executed onMansur Hallaj,53 a 9th century mystic whose gaffes depicted himself as possessing divine attributes. Al-Husayni refutes the link between ‘Yan Haqiqa (seen as hyperactive offshoot of Tijjnaiyyah-Ibrahimiyyah) and the teachings of Ibrahim Inyass,54 issuing a categorical ruling that deifying Ibrahim Inyass is unbelief. Nonetheless, al-Husayni maintains his allegiance to Inyass.55
Al-Husayni’s Islam is Moderation is beyond documenting important aspects and phases of his life and times and it is not confined to constructing his persona as a highly remarkable scholar and leader who received multiple awards of prestigious honors from institutions and bodies within and outside Nigeria such as Commander of the Order of Niger (CON) in 2008, honorary doctorate degree from Nigerian-Turkish Nile University, 2015, Egyptian First Class Award in 1993, the Award of Islamic Preaching by World Islamic Call Society, Libya in 1998, among others.56This seems to be intended to counter the numerous awards Gumi had received including Commander of the Order of the Federal Republic (CFR), honorary doctorate degrees in 1965 from both the University of Ibadan and Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, President Nasser Award in 1963, the Certificate of the International Who is Who of Intellectuals from Cambridge, England in 1982 and King Faisal International Award in 1987.57
Al-Husayni’s book also transcends the mission of exonerating Sufi Shaykhs of the allegations meted out on them by critics, the dismissal of many Sufi rituals as bid’ah (religious innovation) or defending the legitimacy of Tasawwuf as a spiritual pursuit constituting three elements: wird, wazifa anddhikr,58 the hallmarks of tariqa aimed at purifying the soul and which represent the constituent of Ihsan, one of the three hierarchical spiritual levels that make up the Islamic religion as a universal faith. Instead, al-Husayni’s work is a calculated response to Where I Stand in which Gumi, ironically, makes not up to 3 mentions of al-Husayni, which are nonetheless, either in favorable terms or at worst neutral tone. In contrast, al-Husayni makes copious references to Gumi to the point of obsession, thus buttressing the thesis that Islam is Moderationis a belated rejoinder to Gumi’s (early) attack on Sufism.
51 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 160. 52 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 141. 53 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 155. 54 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 158. 55 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 156. 56 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 303. 57 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 195. 58 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 163.
Al-Husayni relates the same story given by Gumi on the appointment of the latter by the federal government as the chairman of National Pilgrims Board with Sufi members to serve as members.59However, he is silent as whether Gumi is right that it was he as the nominated chairman who proposed the names of Sufi Shaykhs including al-Husayni himself to be invited as members of the board, hence the source of Gumi’s surprise and disappointment at Sufi Shaykh’s objection to his chairmanship. Like Gumi, al-Husayni also refers to the peace meetings held between Sufi scholars and how Gumi defied the resolutions and arrangements that emanated from the meetings.60 Since Gumi himself portrays his Sufi counterparts as the party whoreneged on the promises made during the meetings, the issue reflects a blame game and contestation that may only be resolved by a reliably neutral intervention.
While Gumi states that he never used bad language against any of his interlocutors61, al-Husayni contests that in the aftermath of one of the intra-religious meetings held by Muslim scholars, Gumi described some Tijjaniyya Shaykhs as fouls (wawayen malamai in Hausa).62Althoughas hinted earlier, Gumi denies having ever expelled a particular person or group from Islam, it is a common notion within the Sufi milieus that he regarded them as unbelievers. It was obviously this sentiment and the submission of Gumi during peace meetings that motivated al-Husayni to write a book entitled al-Takfir Akhtar Bid’ah Tuhaddid al-Salam wa al-Wahdah bayn al-Muslimin fi Naijiriya.Al-Husayni reviews and criticizes several views and positions held by Gumi, including his controversial fatwa about the importance of politics over prayer,the return of Prophet Isa, the coming of Gog and Magog, the ruling performing a tawaf (circumambulation of Ka’bah) for mutamatti’ before going to Minna and above all, Gumi’s refutation of Sufi beliefs and practices. According to al-Husayni, Gumi’s “entire life and career did not go beyond opposition to Sufism” and declaring certain categories of Muslims as unbelievers.63 Worse still, influenced by mundane and narrow considerations,64Gumi never admitted his mistakes and accepted corrections which he found too insulting, but would brazenly continue to commit similar mistakes,65 although this may contradict Gumi’s claim to learn about his mistakes.66 Not only that, al-Husayni accuses Gumi of not having a full control of his thoughts, in addition to his failure to keep promises he made on crucial decisions with other scholars.67The portrayal of Gumi in Islam is Moderation is not limited to casting him as an intellectual impostor who was very weak in Islamic sciences such as Hadith and Fiqh (86),68 but he was a confused fellow who could not be consistent even with his Wahhabi ideology.69
As an extension of his engagement with Gumi, al-Husayni marshals several allegations against other scholarly figures who might have been considered as revered icons by Gumi and his
59 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 128-129. 60 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 135. 61 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 149-150. 62 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 137. 63 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 233-238. 64 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 138. 65 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 214-217. 66 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 194. 67 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 234. 68 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 86. 69 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 234.
community of followers. In this regard, while acknowledging Ibn Taymiyyah as an accomplished scholar by all standards, he yet questions his integrity towards Islamic cause.70 In the opinion of al-Husayni, Muhammad Ibn Abdulwahhab (whom Gumi, ironically, is entirely silent about in his book) “was not a genuine scholar”,71 and “cannot be counted as a knowledgeable scholar”72. Meanwhile, he concludes that both Ibn Abdulwahhab and Ibn Taymiyyah “have done more harm than good to the image of Islam as a religion”.73Izala whose founding was inspired by Gumi is dismissed by al-Husayni as “the instrument used by real enemies of Islam in order to destabilize the religion from within”,74 paralleling Gumi’s allegation highlighted elsewhere in this paper that Sufi cause was promoted by enemies of Islam.75What however may appear too extraordinarily awkward and perhaps counterproductive to al-Husayni’s moderation and tie with Ahlussunnah in which he openly takes great pride is his portrayal of Caliph Usman bin Affan’s leadership in bad light, insinuating that he took rough and callow decisions which escalated to the degenerations of affairs. As for Mu’awiyah bin Abi Sufyan, al-Husayni explicitly argues that his “central objective was to divide the ummah and not just the Caliphate”.76
Be that as it may, al-Husayni maintains that he bears no grudge against Gumi and he used to visit him in Kaduna, asserting that they yet agreed on certain issues. Reading the autobiographies of the two scholars, one can clearly see that both Gumi and al-Husayni were worried with Nigeria’s political and judicial systems, they were dismayed with the way modernity and secularism have eaten deep into the fabric of the society and therefore they both preached in favour of the Islamic Shari’a. The two scholars had closely monitored international politics and were concerned with the plight of Muslims in Nigeria and other parts of the world.They both believed that traditional rulers no longer hold the influence they used to have and could only reclaim it by properly and sincerely returning to Islam and promoting its cause.77Meanwhile,as Gumi reveals that Arabic togetherwith its branches including Grammar was his favourite subject, which he found easier to grasp, al-Husayni in contrast regarded Arabic Grammar as his toughest subject that he grappled with, even after mastering other various disciplines.
Conclusion
The career of Abubakar Mahmud Gumi (1924-1992) coincided with the era the British colonial administrators were erecting the necessary bureaucratic edifices in the educational, political and judicial sectors, which their successors continued after independence in 1960. He rose to acquire both religious and western education at different places in Nigeria and beyond. A considerable amount of Gumi’s years was spent in the service of Nigeria both before and after the departure of colonial government, and this brought him to interact with key political and public actors, enhancing his influence to spill to other parts of the Muslim world. In this essay, an attempt is made to, through the lens of Gumi’s autobiography assess his personal construction of his career as a teacher, top public servant, reformer and an inspirer of religious reawakening that
70 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 268. 71 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 267. 72 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 267. 73 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 269. 74 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 232. 75 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 166-167. 76 Al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 179. 77 Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, 86 & al-Husayni with Anwar, Islam is Moderation, 209.
will continue to shape the Muslim society in Nigeria and other parts of Africa. This is analytically compared with the reconstruction by al-Husayni of some aspects of Gumi’s scholarship, ideology, views and positions on crucial themes associated with Islamic faith and belief, but above all, on Gumi’s extremely vituperative stance on Sufism.
Disagreement on religious issues is rooted in Islamic scholarship is traceable to the early centuries of Islam, which at times resulted in competition and strained relations. The evolution of schools of jurisprudence owed greatly to positive disagreements and varying readings of Islamic textual injunctions. Meanwhile, sincere religious disagreement is characterized by respect and maintenance of ethics and principles, but also the uncompromising stance to stick to the truth and to accept it if it comes from the interlocutor. Gumi has disagreed with many views and he preached against whatever he considered Islamically wrong, but as he presented his arguments at least in his recollection of what transpired between him and other scholars, he not only showed respect to them but did not hide that he studied under some of them. On the other hand however, Gumi is portrayed in the milieus of his detractors particularly in Islam is Moderation as an intellectual lightweight who did not understand much of the issues he delved into. It will only amount to mulishness to insist that Gumi was not a scholar after having recorded such resounding success in his teaching and missionary career. If al-Husayni was personally confident in his erudition and went on sojourns outside Nigeria including to Saudi Arabia in search for certification only, after having adequately read locally, then in Gumi’s case, it was successful teaching career and collection of works that were assessed by a body of accomplished scholars all over the world, which eventually earned him the King Faisal Award and other prestigious honors.
In summary, al-Husayni does not hide his disappointment with the entire career and mission of Gumi nor does he recognize the value of his intellectual legacy. This may arguably betray the outlook and reputation of tolerance and moderation which al-Husayni has built over the decades. In my casual discussion with scholars and comrades around who are familiar with the works and attitudes of al-Husayni, they expressed doubt on the ascriptions of some of the controversial views lodged in his book to him, to the point that some alleged that there may be interpolations and mistranslations of views and utterances that may not have been the actual position of the Shaykh. Examining the life and career of scholars like Gumi is significant in that too much lessons can be derived which are useful for posterities; the bravery, intrepidity, humility, pan-Islamism, activism, and all other qualities of Gumi are worthy for emulation by upcoming scholars. It is noteworthy that excessive materialism and lust for undue fame as evidenced by the goings-on on social media and other platforms among some scholars not excluding Gumi’s, are replacing the values and ideals lived by Gumi. The culture of engaging with interlocutor through writing and intellectual exchanges through private, decent and unpublicized means, which in Gumi’s times used to reflect the thriving scholarly tradition, no longer takes place.
Comments