Introduction

Islam is not only a religion in the usual sense of the word but also a socio-political order, world view and a way of life in which all aspects of human needs are physically, mentally and spiritually fulfilled409Islam found its way to West Africa as early as the eight' century C.E.1 With the spread of Islam, many Muslims mixed the Islamic practice with those of their traditional beliefs, which

409 Sawaba Yusuf Isa: Islamic Da’wah And Its Development In Takum Local Government Area Of Taraba State, From 1960-2020: Problems And Prospects. M.A Disertation Submitted to the department of Islamic Studies and Shariah, in Pertial fulfilment for the award of M.A in Islamic Studies, Bayero University Kano 2024 p. 1 and see 409 Bello, Muhammad, Calip: Letter to Muslims, Compliment of the Sultanate Councile.Bello Isa Ibrahim: Assessment of the Advents and Development of Islam Among Jukuns People in Southern Taraba. Unpublished M. ED Submitted to department of arts and social science education. Faculty of Education. Ahmadu Bello University Zaria, 2017 Pp.10-11 they inherited from their ancestors, and which contradict the teaching of Islam.410 As a result, Islamic reform movements emerged in many countries in Sub-Saharan Africa with a mission to purify the Islamic principles from what they had identified as Bid’ah, loosely translated as (innovation), on the basis of the saying of the Prophet (p.b.u.h) "Every bidah is a sin and a sin leads to Hell”.411 Among the Islamic movements that initiated reformism in Africa were the Mahdiyya in Sudan and al-Sanusiyya in Libya. Nigeria was no exception to what was happening in the continent. In spite of the Islamic awareness that has spread throughout the society, the proper application of the Islamic teachings was still lacking. Worst still, the rulers often compelled their Muslim subjects to patronize the un-Islamic traditional cults. The region had been plunged into a state of degeneration and the government was utterly corrupt. In order to optimize their ill-gotten gains, the rulers burdened their people with heavy taxation, and confiscation of property if they withheld.412 This socio-political fiasco necessitated the emergence of the confrontational jihad that culminated in the establishment of an Islamic Caliphate known as Sokoto Caliphate (1810) that continued until the turn of the twentieth century (1903).The development of Islamic reform movement in the twentieth century Nigeria was characterized by the emergence of two major movements: Sufism as represented by the Qadiriyya and Tijaniyya Sufi orders413 and anti-Sufism as represented by Izala.414 Islamic practice in Northern Nigeria has historically been intertwined with various cultural and local traditions, including the influence of Sufi mysticism. Over time, however, these traditions, often referred to as syncretic, began to be criticised by reformist scholar, Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi; a leading figure in Islamic reform in Nigeria. He became a prominent critic in Nigeria that frowned atsuch practicesas innovations (bidʿah) that is clearly strayed from the doctrine of Islamic belief. Gumi’s teachings, which aimed to reform Islam in accordance with the Sunnah, laid the foundation for the establishment of Jama’atu Izalatil Bid’ah Wa Iqamatus

410 Huzaifa Aliyu Jangebe: Islamic Reform in Nigeria: The Contribution of Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Vol. 5, No. 9; September 2015 p. 177. Access https://ijhss.thebrpi.org/journals/Vol_5_No_9_September_2015/19.pdf See also Abdurrahman, Doi, Islam and Multi-religious Society: Nigeria, a Case study, (Kuala Lumpur: A.S Noordeen, 1992 p. 8 411Usman Sayyid Ahmad al-Bili, Some Aspects of Islam in Africa, (U.K: Ithaca press, 1 stedn., 2008, pp 49- 50. 412Muhammad Ishaq bin Khuzaimah, Sahih ibn Khuzaimah, vol, 3, (ed, by) Mustafa al-Aazami, (Beirut: al-Makhtab al-Islami, 1980, p. 143. Also see Balogun, Ismail A. B, The Life and Works of Uthman Dan Fodio: The Muslim Reformer of West Africa,Lagos: Islamic Publications Bureau, 1975 p. 15 413Sufism played an important role in the expansion of Islam in Nigeria. In fact, Islam and Sufism had penetrated the continent at the same time, and their spread was simultaneous. The two Sufi orders which have greatly influenced Nigeria are the Qadiriyya and the Tijaniyya. The Qadiriyya order was the first to enter West Africa and Nigeria in particular. Eventually, it spread far and wide in the society and, later, influenced the great Sheikh (Usman Dan Fodio), who launched his reform movement in the 19th century. The Tijaniyya order, founded by Sheikh al-Tijani (1737-1815), became widely accepted later and soon its Zawiyas were established in Kano and Borno. Gradually, the Tijaniyya was preferred by the educated youth in Nigeria, and it had more followers than the Qadiriyyaorder. For more details See: Abdurrahman Doi., Islam and MultiReligious, 216-220 414Under the name Jamaat Izalat al-Bidahwa Iqamat al-Sunnah, (Izala), this organization was launched in Jos, Plateau State, on 12 March 1978, to counteract the activities of the Sufi brotherhood. It regarded itself as a follower of Sunnah. See Muhammad Sani Umar, “Changing Islamic identity in Nigeria from the 1960s to the 1980s: From Sufism to anti-Sufism” in Muslim Identity and Social Change in Sub-Saharan Africa, edited by Louis Brenner (London: c. Hurst & co, 1993), p. 167.

Sunnah (Izala), a movement dedicated to practising what Gumi identified as extraneous influences.This study seeks to analyse Gumi’s theological objections to innovation and syncretism within Islam, examining his teachings in relation to Sufism and the institutional legacy of Izala. It will also investigate the social and political aspects of his reform movement and the ongoing debates concerning religious authenticity in Northern Nigeria.

Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi: Biography and Intellectual Formation

Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi was born in an intellectual family with a history of Islamic learning and commitment to the spread and teaching of pristine Islam for centuries. Abubakar was the son of Alkali-(judge)Mahmud naGumi, ‘he settled at the town of Gummi after decades of wandering teaching Islamic religion, he was easily the most learned man around, considering the age and reputation of those who came to learn from him’. His grandfather was Malam Muhammad Marina, the son of Sheikh Aliyu Barou el-Badawi, an Arab from Bedouin nomads, Muhammad Marina was one of the three children of el-Badawi. They were all men and, like their father, they devoted themselves to Islamic scholarship415. El-Badawi’s settlement in Hausaland was assumed to be the same period when as other Arabs and Berber scholars had influx especially in cities of Kano and Katsina for Islamic scholarship416. Abubakar Gumi’s mother was Amina; she came from a famous Fulani clan known as Fulani Moure. Her home town was Tambuwal, a local government in the present Sokoto State.Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi was born on 7 November 1924 in Gummi, currently located in Zamfara State, Nigeria.

Gumi began his education under the tutelage of his father Malam Mahmud Na Gumi. He memorized the Qur`an and some important books of the Maliki school of thought, such as Risalah Abi Zaid al-Qairawani, and attended the traditional Islamic school, popularly known as „Makarantar allo’. The traditional Islamic school in the northern part of Nigeria had experienced from the pre-colonial and post-colonial period to present day two tracks, the first known as Makarantar allo (Traditional slate school), and the second Makarantar ilimi (Advanced traditional school)417 in addition, at a tender age, when he barely started to learn how to speak, Abubakar commenced receiving instruction and lesson from his mother, who also a scholar was teaching other women from far and wide. The intellectual scene created in the region as a legacy

415Muktar Umar Bunza, Labdo Abdullahi: Comparative Islamic Reform Philosophies in Muslim West Africa: A Societal Contextual Comparison of Shehu Danfodiyo 1754-1817 and Abubakar Gumi 1924-1992. Ternational Journal Of Research And Innovation In Social Science (Ijriss) Issn No. 2454-6186 | Doi: 10.47772/Ijriss |Volume Viii Issue I January 2024 P. 436. See also Abubakar Gumi with I. A. Tsiga, Where I Stand, Spectrum Books Limited, Lagos, 1992, pp. 1-2.

416Abubakar Gumi with Tsiga, Where I Stand, p. 2. 417 Huzaifa Aliyu Jangebe. Political Thought: An Assessment Of Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi`S Thought On Politics And Governance In Nigeria. ISRG Journal of arts Humanitie and Social ScienceJournal homepage: https://isrgpublishers.com/isrgjahss Volume – II Issue-V (September-October) 2024 p. 420. Also see Muhammad Sani Umar, Islam and Colonialism: Intellectual Responses of Muslims of Northern Nigeria to British Colonial Rule, (Leiden Brill: Boston, 2006 pp, 161-162; AliyuAbubakar, alThaqafah al-Arabiyyah fiNajeria, Beirut: Mu´assasatAbd al-Hafiz al-Bassat, 1972.

of the Caliphate established by Shehu Usmanu Dan Fodiyo, learning and ulama were regarded in high esteem, had hugely left imprint on his life and the search for knowledge.418

His educational foundation in Islamic sciences was supplemented by formal instruction in both Arabic and Western educational institutions, thereby shaping his intellectual perspective.Moreover, in 1933, at the age of nine years, he began his western education at Dogon Daji elementary school. At the school, Abubakar Gumi demonstrated his utmost competence, he was shortly nominated, on account of his extraordinary Islamic knowledge, as Hakimin Sallah (Religious Prefect) for the students in charge of all their religious activities. Thereafter, based on his impressive performance, he was promoted to standard two after spending only one term in standard one. After spending one year in the elementary school at Dogon Daji, he was transferred in 1936 to Sokoto Middle School, currently named (Sultan Ward Primary School Sokoto)419.

After a successful journey that lasted for six years with bountiful achievements at the Sokoto Middle School, he decided to pursue his studies at Kano law School. Besides attending regular courses, students of Kano Law College had adequate time to privately pursue other readings. Having successfully completed his studies at the law school, Gumi returned to Sokoto, where his service was urgently requested. Then he remained there for some years before pursuing, in 1952, a two-year further education at the School for Arabic Studies in Kano, where he got a higher elementary training certificate. Eventually, in view of his excellent grades and performance, Gumi was sponsored for a Higher Diploma in education at the Bakht al-Rida Institute of Education in the de facto British colony of Sudan from 1955 to 1956.420

In addition, after Gumi attended the School of Arabic Studies in Kano and subsequently pursued studies at an educational institution in Sudan, he was introduced to Salafi ideologies that would significantly influence his understanding and practice of Islam.In 1962, Gumi was appointed Grand Khadi of the Northern Region of Nigeria, a position that rendered him a highly influential figure in Islamic jurisprudence421. His role as a judge within the Shariah courts established him as a central authority within the religious and legal framework of Northern Nigeria. During this period, Gumi began to criticise the increasing influence of Sufism and syncretism in Islamic practice, advocating instead for a return to the pure form of Islam as exemplified by the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) and his companions.

In addition to his carrier in public services in Nigeria, which was then dominated by the British colonialists; it was extremely difficult for a reformist scholar, who often opposed colonial

418Muktar Umar Bunza, Labdo Abdullahi: Comparative Islamic Reform Philosophies in Muslim West Africa: A Societal Contextual Comparison of Shehu Danfodiyo 1754-1817 and Abubakar Gumi 1924-1992 p. 436 419Huzaifa Aliyu Jangebe: Islamic Reform in Nigeria: The Contribution of Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi p 177. Also see Ahmad HarunaSokoto,ShahararrenMalami[The Famous Scholar], Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi, (Sokoto: Sokoto Newspaper Company limited, 1995) p. 13. 420 Muhammad Sani Umar, Islam and Colonialism: Intellectual Responses of Muslims of Northern Nigeria to British Colonial Rule, (Leiden Brill: Boston, 2006 pp 161-162; also see AliyuAbubakar, al-Thaqafah al-ArabiyyahfiNijeria, (Beirut: Mu´assasatAbd al-Hafiz al-Bassat, 1972). 421Ahmad Sanusi Gumbi, Rayuwar Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi, [The Life of Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi], Kaduna: Gumbi Enterprises, 1986, p. 4.

policies, to be employed. However, his case was an exception. He occupied many positions in public offices. Thus, after he graduated from law school, he was posted as a scribe to the office of the then chief judge, Sokoto province. In 1956, Sardauna appointed him as first Nigerian Pilgrims` officer to the Holy land, and in 1960 the Deputy GrandQadi of northern Nigeria. Subsequently, he served as the Grand Qadi of northern Nigeria, from 1962 to 1967422.Besides these positions, he was also appointed a member of the management team of King Faisal Bank, founded in 1976. He also served as a member of the supreme council of several universities, such as the Islamic University of Madinah, Saudi Arabia, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria and the University of Ibadan,423 Nigeria.

Gumi’s Analysis of Innovation (Bidʿah) and Syncretism.

The word Bid’ah in Arabic linguistically means something new or unprecedented. In the Qur’an, Allah says: He is the Originator of the heavens and the earth.Qur’an 2:117. Here, the root conveys the meaning of creating something without precedent.From an Islamic law point of view, Bid’ah means adding something new to the religion that wasn’t there when the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ lived, and that isn’t found in the Qur’an or the Sunnah. Scholars say that the problem with Bid’ah is when someone presents a new idea as if it’s part of the religion, which can change how worship or beliefs are done. But not all new things are bad. Some new ideas are not good, but others can be good if they help achieve the goals of Sharia, which are called Maqasid al-Sharia424.The major preoccupation of Sheikh Gumi was combating innovations. The Arabic word bidah is derived from the verb badaah, which literally means to originate, introduce or to be inventive in a manner not done before425. Technically, in Islamic law, a bida` is defined by the prominent Islamic scholar ibn Rajab al-Hanbali as follows: “Any form of worship which has no basis in the Shariah to warrant its legislation”426.Muslims jurists had classified bidah into five: obligatory, recommended, forbidden, disliked and permitted. But these classifications are seemingly contestable. The Prophet (p.b.u.h), nonetheless, had generalized all bida`, and refers to them as “novelties” in authentic hadith. The Prophet said, as narrated by Muslim: whoever introduces into this matter of ours (Islam) which does not belong to it, it will be rejected427

For Gumi, innovation (bidʿah) referred to any practice, belief, or custom introduced into Islam that lacked an explicit basis in the Qur’an and Sunnah. He contended that many practices prevalent among Nigerian Muslims, particularly those associated with Sufi orders such as the Tijaniyya, represented innovations that diverged from the fundamental teachings of Islam.

On the authority of Irbad bin Sariah, said: The messenger of Allah gave us a sermon by which our hearts were filled with fear and tears came to our eyes. We said: "O Messenger of Allah, it is as though this is a farewell sermon, so counsel us."

422 Abubakar Mahmud Gumi & Isma`il A. Tsiga, Where I Stand, Ibadan: Spectrum books, 1992 pp 137.-178 423John Paden, Ahmadu Bello Sardauna of Sokoto: Values and Leadership in Nigeria, Zaria: Hudahuda publishing company, 1986 p.548. 424Bid’ah Meaning in Islam: Types, Examples, and Scholarly Views. Access https://ulumalazhar.com/bidah-meaning/ on 6 january 2026. 425 Muhammad b. Mukrim b. Manzur, Lisan al-Arab, vol. 8, Beirut: Dar Sadir, 1st edn.,1990, p. 6. 426Abd al-Rahman b. Ahmad b. Rajab, JamiulUlumwa al-Hikam, Beirut: Dar al-Maarifah, 1999, p. 266. 427 Muhammad bin Isa al-Tirmizi, al-Jamii al-SahihSunan al-Timizi, vol. 4, 2676, Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath, 2000, p. 44.

He said: “I counsel you to fear Allah and to give absolute obedience even if a slave becomes your leader. Verily he among you who lives [long] will see great controversy, so you must keep to my Sunnah and to the Sunnah of the rightly-guided khulafa - cling to them stubbornly. Beware of newly invented matters, for every invented matter is an innovation and every innovation (bidah) is a going astray, and every going astray is in Hell-fire”.428

According to Sheikh Gumi, bida` can be categorized into two main broad forms: whether it concerns Iman (faith) or Muamalat, (social dealings).429 To him, a bida` in muamalat is of three types. The first is wajib (obligatory). The second category is a mustahab (recommended) innovation. The third type is amubah (permitted) innovation.430 But, for bida` on Iman (faith), Sheikh Gumi stated: “On no account could this type of innovation be allowed in matters relating to faith, like the articles of belief, prayers or other rituals.431”According to the above quotation, Sheikh Gumi was of the opinion that all innovations in faith are blameworthy, in fact, they constitute a major sin. Therefore, the concept of a good innovation in faith is simply unacceptable. He probably based his strong rejection of innovations on several authentic prophetic traditions that admonishes new invented practices in Islam. One of the famous hadith is the following: Whosoever introduces into matter of ours, (Islam), something that does not belong to it, it is to be rejected. Gumi regarded practices such as veneration of saints, seeking intercession through deceased individuals, and the celebration of the Prophet Muhammad’s birthday (mawlid) asIslamicdeviations from authentic Islamic practice.According to Gumi, such practices were not merely theological errors but also exemplified spiritual corruption. He promoted a purer, scripturally grounded interpretation of Islam, explicitly dismissing mystical practices and interpretations lacking a clear foundation in the Qur’an or Hadith. His position was that any religious act not directly attributed to the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) or his companions was considered an innovation and was therefore prohibited.

Syncretism and Its Rejection

Syncretism the blending of Islamic doctrines with indigenous customs and pre-Islamic religious traditions constituted a central dimension of Islamic practice that Gumi vehemently opposed. In Northern Nigeria, Islam has historically interacted with local cultural systems, resulting in the incorporation of indigenous practices into religious life432. These include the veneration of local saints, ritual visits to graves, the invocation of spiritual intermediaries, and the use of charms or talismans believed to offer protection or divine favor433. While such practices are often justified within local contexts as expressions of spirituality or cultural continuity, Gumi viewed them as serious theological deviations. He argued that these practices undermined the principle of tawḥīd (absolute monotheism), which he regarded as the foundational pillar of Islamic belief

428 Muhammad bin Isa al-Tirmizi, al-Jamii al-SahihSunan al-Timizi, vol. 4, 2676, Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath, 2000, p. 44. 429 Gumi &Tsiga, 147. 430 Gumi &Tsiga, 148 431 Gumi &Tsiga, 149 432Loimeier, Roman, Islamic Reform and Political Change in Northern Nigeria, Evanston:Northwestern University Press 1997. 433Kyari, Muhammad, The Changing Resources of the Ummah to the Challenges of Western Education: Recent Trends in Maiduguri, Al-Ijtihad Vol 6 no. 2 2005 pp. 147-159.

and identity.Gumi’s rejection of syncretism was grounded in a scripturalist understanding of Islam that prioritised the Qur’an and the Sunnah as the sole legitimate sources of religious authority434. From his perspective, the introduction of indigenous customs into Islamic worship constituted bid‘ah (reprehensible innovation), which distorted the original message of Islam and led to doctrinal corruption. He consistently maintained that Islam, as exemplified by the Prophet Muhammad and the early Muslim community (al-salaf al-ṣāliḥ), was characterised by theological purity, ritual simplicity, and direct devotion to God without intermediaries. Consequently, Gumi advocated a reformist project aimed at purifying Islamic practice by eliminating cultural accretions and mystical embellishments, thereby restoring what he perceived as the authentic and unadulterated form of Islam.

Gumi’s opposition to syncretism is best understood within the broader framework of Salafist reformism, a transnational Islamic movement that calls for a return to the beliefs and practices of the al-salaf al-ṣāliḥ (the pious predecessors). Salafism emphasises strict adherence to the Qur’an and Sunnah, the rejection of bid‘ah (religious innovations), and the uncompromising affirmation of tawḥīd as the core of Islamic faith. In this reformist paradigm, any religious practice not explicitly grounded in early Islamic sources is regarded as a deviation that threatens the doctrinal purity of Islam435. Gumi’s theological orientation closely mirrored this Salafist outlook, particularly in his insistence that Islam must be purified of indigenous customs, mystical practices, and symbolic rituals that had become embedded in Northern Nigerian Muslim society. His reformist agenda thus aligned with Salafism’s broader objective of religious purification and moral renewal, positioning him as a key figure in the localisation of Salafi thought in Nigeria.

In contrast, Sufi perspectives in Northern Nigeria adopt a more accommodative approach to religious practice, one that recognises the historical and cultural contexts in which Islam has been lived and transmitted. Sufism, particularly as expressed through established ṭuruq (such as the Qadiriyya and Tijaniyya), places strong emphasis on spiritual discipline, ethical refinement, and closeness to God through devotional practices. Practices such as saint veneration, grave visitation, dhikr (remembrance of God), and the use of symbolic objects are understood by Sufi436 adherents not as violations of tawḥīd but as legitimate means of spiritual mediation and moral cultivation. From this perspective, local customs are often integrated into Islamic practice as culturally meaningful expressions of faith rather than as theological innovations.

Gumi sharply contested these Sufi interpretations, arguing that the attribution of spiritual efficacy to saints, objects, or intermediaries constituted a subtle form of shirk (associating partners with God). He maintained that such practices blurred the distinction between divine and human agency and diverted believers from direct reliance on God. Whereas Sufi scholars often defend these practices through theological reasoning, historical precedent, and experiential spirituality, Gumi dismissed such justifications as departures from the normative

434Abdul-Wahhab, M. bin, Kitab At-Tauhid, Translated by compilation and research department, dar-us-Salam, Dar-us-Salam Publications, Riyadh-Saudi Arabia 1996. 435Abul-Qasem Muhammad: The ethics of Al-Ghazali: A Composite ethics in Islam. 2nd edition, new York 1978. 436Ibrahim, Muhammad Mansur, Matsayin Karatun Boko da A ikin Gwamnati a Musulunci(The Position of Islam on Western Education and Public Service) Paper presented at aJIBWIS seminar held in Bauchi 8 – 10 May 2009.

Islam of the Prophet and his companions. This ideological confrontation reflects a deeper epistemological divide between Salafist scripturalism and Sufi experiential religiosity.

Ultimately, the tension between Gumi’s Salafist reformism and Sufi perspectives in Northern Nigeria represents more than a theological disagreement; it embodies competing visions of Islamic authority, religious authenticity, and the role of culture in shaping religious life. While Salafist reformism, as articulated by Gumi, seeks to standardise Islamic practice through textual orthodoxy and doctrinal uniformity, Sufism affirms a pluralistic and historically embedded understanding of Islam that accommodates spiritual diversity and cultural expression. This contrast has had enduring implications for intra-Muslim relations, religious contestation, and the configuration of Islamic authority in Northern Nigeria.\

The Establishment of Jama’atu Izalatil Bid’ah Wa Iqamatus Sunnah (Izala) and Its Mission

In 1978, the establishment of Jama’atu Izalatil Bid’ah Wa Iqamatus Sunnah (Izala) introduced a framework that was rejected in the context of Gumi’s teachings. Izala’s primary objective was to eradicate innovations (bidʿah) from Islamic practice and to reestablish adherence to the authentic Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammad. The movement garnered significant support from individuals who shared Gumi’s concerns regarding the influence of Sufism and syncretic practices within the Muslim community.Izala sought to provide an alternative to the established Sufi orders by emphasizing scripturalism and strict adherence to the Qur’an and Hadith. The movement experienced rapid expansion437, particularly in Northern Nigeria, and established branches throughout the country. Its influence extended beyond religious contexts into social and political spheres, where it began to shape discourses on Islamic identity and reform. The Sufi prominence in Nigeria has not remained unchallenged. In the past three decades, the activities of Jama’atu Izalatul Bid’a wa Ikamatu Sunna (JIBWIS, or Izala) ( Association for the elimination of innovation and the restoration of Sunna) has brought great challenges to the practices of the Sufi Brotherhoods like in other parts of Northern Nigeria. Practices that are not reported in the Qur’an and Sunna of the Prophet (SAW) orijma438came to be questioned by the Izala and with this challenge, rivalry between the established sufi orders and the Izala ensued. Izala claims to be the orthodox sunni and hence its usage of the term ahulul sunna wal jama’a i.e. brotherhood for the sunna to describe and distinguish itself from the Sufi orders who equally claim orthodoxy. Izala is prominently present in all the states and local governments of the northeast. Since 1990 however, it became divided into two, one faction popularly referred to as “Bushawa” Izala with its base in Jos led by Sheikh Samaila Idris (1937 – 2000) and the other “Saddam” Izala based in Kaduna under Sheikh Musa Maigandu. Several events led to this division which cannot be discussed here439 but the Gulf War in 1990 was probably the final

437Aliyu, Tanimu, Ingantacen Tarihin Jama’atu Izalatil Bid’ah wa Ikamatu Sunnah (1),Bauchi: New Era Production 1999. 438Dikko, Hassan Abubakar, Achievements of the Izala movementfrom its commencement todate, unpublished M.A thesis (Islamic Studies), University of Jos (2000). 439See Aliyu, Tanimu, Ingantacen Tarihin Jama’atu Izalatil Bid’ah wa Ikamatu Sunnah (1),Bauchi: New Era Production 1999 and Dikko, Hassan Abubakar, Achievements of the Izala movementfrom its commencement to date, unpublished M.A thesis (Islamic Studies), University of Jos (2000)..

incident that divided the two groups440when the ‘Bush camp’ argued that the war was not a religious one because of its belief that Saddam Hussein did not deserve Muslim sympathy. The reason advanced was that Saddam had earlier on attacked Kuwait, a fellow Muslim country. The ‘Saddam’ faction, on the other hand, saw the Gulf War as an attack on Muslims by the USA and her allies.441

Izala’s Methods of Dissemination

Izala’s dissemination strategies were central to its organisational growth and ideological success in Northern Nigeria. Under the intellectual leadership of Abubakar Gumi and other prominent reformist figures, the movement adopted a multi-layered communication strategy designed to penetrate both urban and rural Muslim communities. Public preaching sessions (waʿz) constituted the backbone of Izala’s outreach, providing accessible platforms for articulating reformist critiques of bidʿah and syncretic religious practices. These lectures were often confrontational in tone, deliberately structured to provoke theological debate and to challenge the authority of established Sufi leaders. By framing religious reform as a return to “authentic Islam,” Izala preachers positioned their message as both doctrinally legitimate and socially urgent442 Beyond face-to-face preaching, Izala made strategic use of modern mass media, particularly radio broadcasting, which significantly expanded the reach of Gumi’s ideas. Radio programmes allowed reformist teachings to transcend geographical and literacy barriers, enabling Izala to communicate directly with illiterate audiences and populations in remote rural areas who might otherwise lack access to formal religious instruction. Through sermons, Qur’anic exegesis, and call-and-response formats, these broadcasts helped normalise Salafi interpretations of Islam within everyday religious discourse. Scholars have noted that Izala’s effective deployment of radio marked a decisive shift in Islamic preaching in Nigeria, signalling a move toward mass-mediated religious authority443

Printed materials also played an important role in consolidating Izala’s ideological influence. Pamphlets, booklets, and polemical texts many authored by Gumi himself were circulated widely and used as instructional tools in mosques, study circles, and informal learning spaces. These texts provided doctrinal justification for Izala’s reformist agenda, particularly its rejection of syncretism and Sufi devotional practices, while offering simplified theological arguments grounded in the Qur’an and Sunnah. The availability of such materials contributed to the

440Anwar, Auwalu, The struggle for influence and identity: The ulama in Kano 1937-1989, unpublished M.A thesis (History) University of Maiduguri, 1989 441Muhammad Nur Alkali et-al: Overview Of Islamic Actors In Northeastern Nigeria.Nigeria Research Network (NRN) Oxford Department of International Development Queen Elizabeth House University of Oxford. 2012

442 Kane, O. Muslim Modernity in Postcolonial Nigeria. 2003 Brill.

443 Kane, O. Beyond Timbuktu: An Intellectual History of Muslim West Africa. Harvard University Press. .2016 also see Larkin, B. Signal and Noise: Media, Infrastructure, and Urban Culture in Nigeria. Duke University Press. 2008 standardisation of Salafi discourse and reinforced the movement’s claim to textual orthodoxy 444

In addition to preaching and media outreach, Izala invested heavily in the establishment of educational institutions aligned with Gumi’s reformist vision. These institutions ranging from Qur’anic schools to structured Arabic and Islamic studies centres were designed to produce a new generation of Muslim scholars and preachers committed to Salafi principles. The curriculum in these schools emphasised ʿaqīda (creed), hadith studies, and jurisprudence grounded in scriptural literalism, while explicitly discouraging mystical interpretations and culturally embedded religious practices. Through this educational project, Izala sought not merely to reform popular religious practice but to reshape the future landscape of Islamic authority in Northern Nigeria by institutionalising its ideological framework445Collectively, these dissemination strategies enabled Izala to transform Gumi’s reformist ideas from elite theological critiques into a mass religious movement. By combining traditional preaching with modern communication technologies and institutional education, Izala successfully challenged the dominance of Sufi orders and redefined patterns of religious engagement, authority, and contestation within Northern Nigerian Islam.446

Controversies and criticisms of Gumi’s teachings, including opposition from Sufi orders

Sheikh Abubakar Mahmoud Gumi’s teachings encountered substantial opposition from established Sufi orders, which criticised his practices as un-Islamic. Leaders and followers of Sufi groups accused Gumi of undermining the spiritual depth and tradition of Sufism, a vital aspect of Nigerian Islam for centuries. Debates between Gumi’s supporters and Sufi factions were often intense, with both sides accusing each other of misrepresenting Islamic principles. Critics of Gumi further argued that his strict rejection of Sufism alienated many Muslims who derived spiritual solace from Sufi practices. They maintained that Gumi’s focus on the literal interpretation of scripture neglected the historical and cultural contexts in which Islam had developed in West Africa.

Social and Political Implications

The ideological divide between Gumi’s adherents and traditional Muslims had significant social and political repercussions. The movement’s rejection of conventional Islamic practices fostered divisions within Muslim communities, sometimes leading to tensions and violence. In certain cases, the rhetoric employed by Izala leaders exacerbated sectarianism, with accusations of heresy directed at Sufi Muslims.From a political standpoint, Gumi’s reformist objectives

444 Loimeier, R “The Izala Movement in Nigeria.” Islamic Africa, 2012.

445 Loimeier, R. Muslim Societies in Africa. Indiana University Press. . 2017

446 Paden, J. Religion and Political Culture in Kano. University of California Press. 1973 see also Loimeier, R. Islamic Reform and Political Change in Northern Nigeria. Northwestern University Press. 1997 challenged the prevailing power structure, particularly in Northern Nigeria, where Sufi orders held substantial influence over local governance and social institutions. As a result, the emergence of Izala posed a threat to the political and religious authority of established Muslim leaders and their allies within the emirate system.

Legacy of Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi

Sheikh Gumi’s legacy lies in the establishment of a lasting reformist movement that continues to shape Islamic practice in Northern Nigeria. Through Izala, Gumi’s teachings have had a profound impact on the way Islam is practised and understood in the region. The movement’s emphasis on returning to the Qur’an and Sunnah has been influential in challenging the dominance of Sufism and promoting a more scripturally-based understanding of Islam.Moreover, Gumi’s contributions to Islamic scholarship, particularly in the areas of Qur’anic translation and Islamic jurisprudence, have left an enduring intellectual legacy that continues to inspire contemporary reformist thought in Nigeria and beyond. Ongoing Divisions within Nigerian Islam Nevertheless, Gumi’s legacy is also characterized by the persistent divisions within Nigerian Islam, which have shaped the country’s religious dynamics over several decades. The ideological conflict between reformist Muslims, who advocate for modernization and a return to core Islamic principles, and traditionalist Muslims, who emphasize the preservation of longstanding customs, continues to influence Nigeria’s religious and political landscape. Although the Izala Society has emerged as a prominent Sunni reformist movement advocating for a strict interpretation of Islam and opposing Sufi practices, it remains in conflict with numerous Sufi groups, such as the Qadiriyya and Tijaniyya, which emphasize mysticism and local syncretic traditions. Debates regarding innovation (bid‘a) and syncretism defined as the blending of Islamic practices with indigenous beliefs remain intense and often impact social cohesion and political allegiances.

Recommendations

1. Future studies should examine the long-term socio-political influence of the Izala movement on Nigeria’s democratic processes. Specifically, researchers could analyse how Gumi’s scriptural purism evolved from a solely religious reform into a political identity that continues to influence voting behaviour and governance in Northern Nigeria. 2. In order to mitigate sectarianism, stakeholders in Northern Nigeria should prioritize intra-faith dialogue. By emphasizing the shared ethical principles outlined in the Qur’an and Sunnah, which Gumi championed, various Islamic sects can identify common ground to address contemporary social challenges such as poverty and education. This approach encourages cooperation rather than focus on doctrinal differences that have historically contributed to division. 3. Modern reformist movements should emulate Gumi’s dedication to scriptural literacy and education, while adapting his approach to better suit Nigeria’s diverse societal context. Educational curricula within these movements must balance the emphasis on "scriptural purity" with the promotion of religious tolerance, as well as highlight the historical diversity of Islamic thought, in order to prevent the radicalization of sectarian divisions.

4. It is advisable for the Nigerian government and civil society organisations to engage more extensively with reformist religious leaders. Recognising these leaders as integral to the region’s social fabric that enables the state to more effectively manage the complexities of religious change and leverage religious reform to promote national stability, rather than permitting it to serve as a source of division. 5. It is also recommended that any successful religious reform in Northern Nigeria should reconcile the pursuit of doctrinal authenticity with the essential goal of maintaining communal harmony. Future reform initiatives ought to aim to uphold the rigour of Gumi’s teachings while reducing the exclusionary rhetoric that has historically contributed to sectarian tensions. Conclusion Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi’s teachings, which oppose innovation and syncretism, represent a significant chapter in the religious history of Northern Nigeria. His emphasis on returning to the authentic teachings of Islam, as outlined in the Qur’an and Sunnah, has profoundly influenced the region’s religious landscape and laid the foundation for reformist movements such as Izala. While Gumi’s focus on scriptural purity has heightened awareness and adherence to Islamic texts, it has also sparked controversy, division, and sectarianism within Nigerian Islam. Consequently, Gumi’s legacy embodies both reformative and contentious elements, reflecting the intricate dynamics of religious change within a pluralistic society. Reference

• Aliyu, Huzaifa. “Islamic Reform in Nigeria: The Contribution of Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi.” International Journal of Humanities and Social Science, vol. 5, no. 9, 2015, pp. 10– 15. • Gumi, Abubakar Mahmud. The Islamic Reformation in Northern Nigeria. ResearchGate, 1991. • “Obituary: Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi.” The Independent, 16 Sept. 1992, www.independent.co.uk/news/people/obituary-sheikh-abubakar-mahmud-gumi- 1551628.html. Accessed 4 Dec. 2025. • “Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi.” King Faisal Prize, kingfaisalprize.org, www.kingfaisalprize.org/en/shaikh-abu-bakr-mahmoud-gumi/. Accessed 4 Dec. 2025. • Jangebe, Huzaifa Aliyu. “Islamic Reform in Nigeria: The Contribution of Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi.” International Journal of Humanities and Social Science, vol. 5, no. 9, Sept. 2015. ResearchGate.